New Delhi: On Tuesday, after the Indian Air Force (IAF) struck targets in Pakistan and across the Line of Control in Kashmir, social media trends in both countries reflected a mix of celebration, anger and a gung-ho readiness for escalation – even to war – between the nuclear-armed powers.
On Twitter, users who cautioned against war, or called for peace, were aggressively trolled and silenced.
War is young men dying and old men tweeting
— Shilpa Rathnam (@shilparathnam) February 26, 2019
War is young men dying and old men talking – Franklin D Roosevelt (Please troll him as well ?)
— Shilpa Rathnam (@shilparathnam) February 26, 2019
“It was incessant yesterday,” journalist Shilpa Rathnam told The Wire, “ranging from mild reprimands saying the timing of my tweet isn’t right, to outright MC-BC abuse.”
By Wednesday, however, the contesting claims that both countries shot down each others’ aircraft – and eventual videos proving the capture of an IAF pilot, alive and relatively unhurt – seem to have shifted the wind.
Thank you! ?? Only sane citizen voices can compel their governments to find some sense in these insane times. #SayNoToWar https://t.co/PAInoBN0F8
— VISHAL DADLANI (@VishalDadlani) February 27, 2019
Same here. My heart breaks. What if it was my brother or my son arrested by the enemy forces. War benefits no one. It destroys families. It destroys lives.#SayNoToWar https://t.co/Un4ESPzOnt
— Mahwash Ajaz (@mahwashajaz_) February 27, 2019
Videos purportedly of Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman – being pulled from an angry mob by Pakistan Army soldiers, then upright and blindfolded in captivity, then drinking tea – put the first human face on the costs of a possible war.
The only war that Pakistan and India should fight should be against poverty, illiteracy and violence.#SayNotoWar #AntiHateChallenge
— beena sarwar (@beenasarwar) February 20, 2019
Courage is not in warmongering. Courage is in reaching out in peace while fighting terror & hate. Courage is in restraint amidst provocation. War won’t benefit the people of India or Pakistan. It will only bring suffering to the families on both sides of the border #SayNoToWar https://t.co/ACN2HCBumu
— Harsh Mander (@harsh_mander) February 27, 2019
On Twitter, around 2 pm on Wednesday, #SayNoToWar began to trend in both India and Pakistan – as those who opposed escalation found their voices.
“Better sense should prevail” .
A very sensible offer from Prime Minister @ImranKhanPTI#SayNoToWar pic.twitter.com/8AG8LibOTc— Shoaib Akhtar (@shoaib100mph) February 27, 2019
This would be an unpopular opinion, but both govts have flexed their muscles and played to the gallery. Now let them do their job and begin talks to de-escalate the situation. War isn’t the solution. Peace is. #SayNoToWar
— Rajiv Lakshman (@RajivLakshman) February 27, 2019
On both sides #India & #Pakistan there is a lot of hate coming out . Can in this tense time those who desire peace we unite & tweet #SayNoToWar . We want the media in both countries to END this war cry NOW !! #SayNoToWar
— Tehseen Poonawalla (@tehseenp) February 27, 2019
Agree wholeheartedly. #SayNoToWar for sure.. The people of India, Pakistan, and Kashmir cannot afford a war. https://t.co/KfEBsnTLbv
— Amar Gujral (@curiousindelhi) February 27, 2019
The hashtag peaked at around 4:30 pm, appearing on tens of thousands of tweets, rising to #3 nationally in India (after #Abhinandan and #BringBackAbhinandan) and #1 in Pakistan (after #PakistanStrikesBack). Also trending at #5 in Pakistan was the hashtag #PeaceNotWar. It also trended globally, climbing as high as #3 (#Abhinandan was at #2)
To the powers that be, may #WingCommanderAbhinandan return home safely to his family and nation. A whole lot of us are praying for you. Indebted for your selfless service. ??????#SayNoToWar
— Shruti Seth (@SethShruti) February 27, 2019
बहन-चारा !
Women in both countries want peace not war. May this BehenChara
prevail #SayNoToWar https://t.co/MpsELVLuhh— Arfa Khanum Sherwani (@khanumarfa) February 27, 2019
There is no better use for mine and your and everyone’s fingers than to sue for peace and petition to #BringHimBack #BringAbhinandanBack and #SayNoToWar If your patriotism was true, you’d be doing the same, instead of wasting your time trolling me. https://t.co/75WSTN1TwM
— Swara Bhasker (@ReallySwara) February 27, 2019
They remained in these positions at the time of this story’s publication.
I can’t even see these 2 pics (mother of soldiers of India & Pakistan).
Don’t know how much pics we will see if there is war.#SayYesToPeace #SayNoToWar pic.twitter.com/9rxF5dG8bw— Dhawal Odedra (@Dhawal_Odedra) February 27, 2019
You say preemptive strike, I say ice-cream.#SayNoToWar #ConquerTheWild2 pic.twitter.com/wBqoXGsk2K
— WSK (@WajSKhan) February 26, 2019
We are on the brink of a war that nobody in their right mind in either Pakistan or India want. Imran Khan's words should be welcomed. Encourage dialogue, commit to deescalation. Anyone who thinks otherwise should for a moment swap places with Abhinandan & his family #SayNoToWar
— Raunak Kapoor (@RaunakRK) February 27, 2019
Being a Pakistani, I am feeling proud of our PM @ImranKhanPTI for the level of maturity he has shown as a leader in the times of war! Equally, praise-worthy presser of @OfficialDGISPR
Dear Indians, your pilot is our guest! #SayNoToWar
— Kapil Dev (@KDSindhi) February 27, 2019
Loving how people on this side of the border have been mostly advocating for #SayNoToWar and now on my timeline I see most Pakistanis talking about treating the wing commander with respect and dignity and returning him to India. A peaceful people make a peaceful country. ???
— meena gabeena (@gabeeno) February 27, 2019
A sincere thank you to all the Pakistanis who are replying to me saying they don’t want war either, that our captured soldier will be returned to us safe and sound. Thank you for keeping the glimmer of peace alive. pic.twitter.com/hmawB65gC9
— Shilpa Rathnam (@shilparathnam) February 27, 2019