Who is Ursula Von Der Leyen, the Surprise Compromise as European Commission President?

German defence minister Ursula von der Leyen has been named as a candidate for the post of EC president.


She was born in a Brussels suburb a little more than 60 years ago. Now the pursuit of her political career could lead her back to the Belgian and European capital. Discussing key job nominations, the EU’s heads of state and government have come up with the name of Germany defence minister Ursula Von der Leyen.

So now the Christian Democrat politician, who was introduced to the Berlin stage by Chancellor Angela Merkel in 2005 – and who was once briefly treated as a potential successor to Merkel – is set to become head of the European Commission. She would be the Commission’s first-ever female chief, although the European Parliament will only take the actual decision in a couple of days.

Who will take over from Jean-Claude Juncker? Photo: Reuters

A good command of languages

Von der Leyen spent the first 13 years of her life in Brussels. Her father, Ernst Albrecht, who would later become state premier in Lower Saxony, was a high-level official at the EEC and EC, the EU’s predecessor institutions. In contrast to many of her colleagues in the government, Von der Leyen speaks English and French fluently and has always acted with self-confidence on the international stage.

German Defence Minister Ursula von der Leyen attends NATO defence ministers meeting at the Alliance headquarters in Brussels. Photo: Reuters

In several governments led by Chancellor Merkel, Leyen held a variety of ministerial posts. Invariably, she would tackle her new task with great dedication, calling existing structures into question and eventually stirring them up. Occasionally, her determination even produced irritation among her parliamentary party colleagues.

Also read: Denmark’s Youngest Prime Minister to Lead New Government

Ministerial posts

Initially, the mother of seven held the post of family minister between 2005 and 2009. With her sometimes unconventional style, she sent clear signals to the political establishment in Berlin. For example, she initiated a parental assistance program (“Elterngeld”) and oversaw a nationwide expansion of childcare by providing substantial financial support from the German government.

In 2009, then serving in Merkel’s second Cabinet, Von der Leyen, a trained physician, became health minister. Four years later, in December 2013, she switched to the Ministry of Defense. She remained in charge of the latter ministry even after the complicated government formation process in the wake of the 2017 federal elections. Hardly any of her seventeen predecessors, all of them men, managed to hold on to the post for six years.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel speaks with defence minister Ursula von der Leyen (R) during a session of the Bundestag. Photo: Reuters

Prior to taking over at defence ministry (long considered a graveyard for promising German political careers), the ambitious Von der Leyen had a nearly flawless career. She has mostly been loyal to Chancellor Angela Merkel, who counts on her as a solid pillar in her Cabinet.

Mover and shaker

As defence minister, Von der Leyen quickly tackled the armed forces’ problems one by one. The Bundeswehr was and still is afflicted by outdated and defective equipment, ill-conceived arms projects and a severe shortage of experts. By applying a lot of political pressure and by speaking out in public on behalf of the Bundeswehr she achieved an increase in the defence budget – albeit still well short of NATO’s spending targets. And under the catchphrase “personnel turnaround,” the first female German defence minister stopped the downsizing of the armed forces, bolstering troop numbers for the first time since the end of the Cold War.

Also read: Spain Joins France and Germany to Build a Next-Generation Fighter Jet

She scrapped Germany’s fixed cap of 185,000 troops. Under Von der Leyen’s tenure, defence policy became a recognisable element of Germany’s foreign policy. This was also in line with international efforts to fight the “Islamic State” terror militia, which has seen contributions by the German armed forces in several spheres.

German defence minister Ursula von der Leyen walks past a German Bundeswehr armed forces. Photo: Reuters/Fabrizio Bensch

“We’d left behind a period during which the Bundeswehr had been downsized for a long time,” Leyen said in 2017. “The security situation has changed to the effect that the Bundeswehr has to deal with a vast number of challenges, ranging from Syria and Iraq to Mali and the entire mission in the Mediterranean Sea. In addition, the troops have to cope with refugee relief and protection of the eastern border. At the same time, the Bundeswehr and I managed, in a concerted effort, to ‘turn the tanker around,’ as it were – there were turnarounds in the areas of equipment, personnel, and finances.”

Also read: As the Far-Right Culture War Escalates in Germany, Concerns Grow

Asked by DW whether Von der Leyen was a good choice to succeed Jean-Claude Juncker as president of the EU Commission, Greens defense expert Omid Nouripour quipped about the many recent Bundeswehr failings making headlines in Germany: “The situation with respect to the equipment of the German armed forces is not a necessary qualification for the top EU executive job.”

Slip-ups and scandals

Von der Leyen’s reputation as the woman who gets things done has suffered in recent years. This is due to several personnel decisions, but also a number of scandals. During her tenure, too, major arms projects were delayed, and simultaneously right-wing extremist activities in the armed forces and humiliating practices affecting new recruits came to light. Von der Leyen explicitly distanced herself from the armed forces – more so than her predecessors might have dared.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel (L) and French President Francois Hollande pose for pictures in front of the tall ship Gorch Fock. Photo: Reuters/Thomas Peter

Claiming that the Bundeswehr was affected by an “attitude problem” hurt her image among the troops. More recently, she was floundering over the question whether the naval training ship “Gorch Fock” still has a future despite skyrocketing cost overruns in restoration work. And gradually it has been coming to light that a deputy minister employed by Von der Leyen took many liberties, for example hiring a small army of expensive advisers at her own discretion. An investigative committee in Germany’s Bundestag parliament is currently dealing with the case, and Von der Leyen is set to take the witness stand in a few months.

Supports European military cooperation, and more defence spending

Blemishes like these had taken some of the shine off Von der Leyen’s once-impeccable reputation in Berlin in recent months and years. And still, longtime observers maintain that her prospects for a Brussels top job are good. In addition to local knowledge and language skills, she contributed to establishing the structure of the EU defence union. “A European army as a long-term goal and NATO are not opposites but, to me, two sides of the same coin, because it’s important that the Europeans make up a strong pillar within NATO, not just in order to uphold NATO’s credibility but also to have a strong European voice,” she said. In response to US President Donald Trump’s call for a greater military commitment of Germany and Europe, she said: “In my opinion, that’s a fair demand.”

German Labour Minister Ursula von der Leyen (L) and German Chancellor and leader of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU). Photo: Reuters

Also read: Council of Europe Restores Russia’s Voting Rights

Von der Leyen has shown ambition for even higher office in the past. When it fell to the CDU to name a possible presidential successor after the sudden resignation of Horst Köhler in 2010, she temporarily put her name forward. Now, her career could lead her away from German politics and back to her birthplace.

This article was originally published on DW.

Germany’s Scandal-Hit Army Receives Praise From Defence Minister

Amid the criticisms fired at the German Armed Forces, questions of how they should deal with their past have emerged.

Hans-Peter Bartels, parliamentary commissioner for the German armed forces (Bundeswehr) attends an interview with Reuters in Berlin, Germany, May 23, 2017. Credit: Reuters/Fabrizio Bensch

Berlin: Germany‘s armed forces can be proud of their post-war achievements, the defence minister said on Tuesday, responding to a series of scandals involving far-right sympathisers in the Bundeswehr army‘s ranks.

The Bundeswehr, founded in the 1950s as West Germany‘s democratically-controlled army in contrast to the Nazi-era Wehrmacht, is heavily involved in peacekeeping and training missions abroad and has fully integrated women, she said.

Von der Leyen has come under fire for criticising the army following a scandal concerning a high-flying officer accused of planning militant attacks while disguised as an asylum seeker.

That case has triggered one debate over how the armed forces should deal with their past, and another about whether von der Leyen’s criticism had discredited the army‘s 250,000 military and civilian staff.

“After 61 years of the Bundeswehr, we have a proud and impressive history,” the defence minister told reporters. “From that we can develop a much stronger tradition, our own sense of meaning.”

The case of the officer, identified only as Franco A, has stirred up uncomfortable memories because investigators searching barracks after his arrest found dozens of items of World War Two-era memorabilia.

In her initial reaction, Von der Leyen pointed to this as evidence that too little was being done to stamp out far-right sympathies in the forces.

The German parliamentary armed forces ombudsman, Hans-Peter Bartels, whose job is to hear soldiers’ complaints, said her criticisms had caused enormous disquiet throughout the army.

“I don’t know who advised her to let her criticisms be seen so drastically,” he told Reuters. “But now it’s happened and we have to repair the damage […] Every soldier I’ve heard from has a sense of having been targeted by the criticisms.”

Harking to military traditions to foster an esprit de corps among soldiers is difficult for the Bundeswehr, which rejects the militarism of the past and honours officers who disobeyed Hitler and tried to assassinate him.

Speaking to the foreign journalists association, von der Leyen said the Bundeswehr had to draw its sense of pride from its post-war achievements.