Priest Admitted to His Crimes Against 9-Yr-Old Dalit Girl That Day, Say Family, Neighbours

The girl’s parents and other villagers have also accused the police of inaction in the case.

New Delhi: “He accepted that night that he had committed the crime,” Diksha, a neighbour of the nine-year-old Dalit girl who was allegedly raped, murdered and forcibly cremated on Sunday, told The Wire. By “he”, Diksha is referring to Radhey Shyam, a Brahmin priest at a crematorium in Delhi. The victim had gone to this crematorium to fetch water, her parents have said.

While the young girl was away, at around 6 pm, Radhey Shyam called the girl’s mother to the crematorium. When she got there, she was told that her daughter had died after being electrocuted while taking water from the cooler.

“I tried to shake my daughter awake. Her eyes were shut and her lips blackened,” her mother told The Wire. There were also bruises on the girl’s arms and her clothes were drenched. “When I asked the pandit (priest) how my daughter’s clothes had become wet, he got nervous and told me not to call the police.”

The sit-in protest against the incident. Photo: The Wire

According to the mother, the pandit insisted that calling the police would lead to an autopsy “where the child’s organs would be sold”, and that the matter would become a major legal issue for the parents. “He then said, ‘Let me cremate her here instead and end the matter,’ and began preparing for the cremation. I was alone there and helpless,” the girl’s mother continued.

With the child propped on the pyre and the flames ablaze, the pandit asked the mother to leave. “He told me not to go out crying or tell people what had happened.”

Also read: Dalit Man Beaten to Death While in Uttar Pradesh Police’s Custody

Diksha, a neighbour of the victim, told The Wire that she found the girl’s mother in a frantic state. “She told us that her daughter had gotten electrocuted and died. When we asked her where the body was, she told us that the pandit had cremated her.”

Upon hearing this, Diksha and others in the area gathered and made their way to the crematorium. “We called the pandit outside to speak to him. He was intoxicated and dining with the other [accused].” The crowd then entered the crematorium premises and pulled the victim’s body from the flames. By this time, only her feet remained.

As anger flared, the crowd began questioning the priest about the incident, Diksha said. It was at this point, she added, that Radhey Shyam accepted that he had committed a crime. The victim’s mother and others who were at the scene also confirm this – that the priest admitted to raping and killing the child. “The police response seemed ineffective and that’s why people have been protesting here for the last three days,” Disha continued.

In the area where the incident occurred, a sit-in protest site has been established. Activists, lawyers and others from the Valmiki community have been coming here in large numbers and demanding a fast-track hearing of the case and capital punishment for the accused.

These demands come after allegations of police inaction came to the fore.

The victim’s parents. Photo: The Wire

On the night of the crime, the victim’s parents were taken to the police station and held there until the evening of the next day. The girl’s father alleged that when they were giving their testimonies to the police, a local from the area, one Naresh Karotia, arrived at the station and assaulted him in front of the police. “He beat me and abused me in front of the police,” the father said.

Furthermore, the girl’s parents alleged that police officials at the time told them that their daughter had been electrocuted and not raped.

Also read: A Custodial Death, a Protest and Raids that Drove Dalit Villagers Out of Homes

The Wire spoke to the deputy commissioner of police (Southeast Delhi), Ingit Pratap Singh, who said that the parents can file an official complaint regarding the alleged events that took place in the police station. “None of them have given us a complaint yet,” added Singh.

A forensic enquiry is still ongoing.

According to a report by NDTV, a senior police officer has said that the postmortem was inconclusive and the four accused would face lie detector and drug tests. The report also adds that forensic examination of the water cooler found an electric current passing through it.

Four men have been arrested by the police – Radhey Shyam, 55, Lakshmi Narayan, 43, Kuldeep, 63 and Salim, 49 – and they have been charged under Sections 302 (murder), 376 (rape), 506 (criminal intimidation) and 204 (destruction of evidence) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) apart from certain sections of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act and the SC/ST Act.

Four Nuns, Rape Survivor Seek Kerala CM’s Intervention on Transfer Issue

“The aim of the present transfer orders is to pressure and threaten us as all of us are prominent witnesses in the case,” the four nuns alleged in a letter.

Kochi: Four nuns, who took part in a protest demanding the arrest of rape-accused Bishop Franco Mulakkal, have written to the Kerala chief minister, seeking his intervention to ensure that their transfer orders are not effected till the trial is over.

The letter to Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan was written after four of the five nuns, who led the agitation against the bishop last year, were directed to leave their convent in Kottayam district, in compliance with a transfer order issued by their congregation last year.

The survivor nun has also written a separate letter to the chief minister, seeking his help in the matter.

“Their aim is to single me out and to harass and torture me. My life will be in danger if such a situation arises,” she has alleged in her letter.

Their congregation – Missionaries of Jesus under the Jalandhar diocese of the Roman Catholic Church – has directed the nuns to join their previously-assigned convents, according to the transfer orders issued between March and May, 2018.

Also read: Four Nuns Shunted From Kerala Convent for Speaking Against Bishop Franco Mulakkal

The nuns – Alphy, Anupama, Josephine and Ancitta – were served notice by the superior general of the congregation, Regina Kadamthottu, urging them to take up their assigned responsibilities as befitting members of the Missionaries of Jesus congregation.

Sister Nina Rose, who also fought for justice for the survivor nun, has not been asked to leave the convent.

While Sister Alphy has been transferred to a convent at Pakartala in Bihar, sister Ancitta and sister Josephine have been directed to join their convent in Lalmatia, Jharkhand.

Sister Anupama has been asked to report at a convent in Punjab.

In their letter to the chief minister, the nuns alleged that the transfer orders were aimed at splitting them and “to sabotage the case” against Bishop Franco Mulakkal.

“Bishop Franco is supported by some of the church authorities and his henchmen. They are making false propagation and character assassination against us.

“The aim of the present transfer orders is to pressure and threaten us as all of us are prominent witnesses in the case,” the four nuns alleged in the letter.

“They want to split us and put us into different locations in India. We will not be able to appear and give evidence before the court at the trial stage in such a situation,” they said in the letter.

Also read: ‘Bishop Franco Mulakkal Is a Symptom of the Decay of the Church’

The nuns sought Vijayan’s intervention to ensure that all of them could live at the St Francis Mission Home in Kuravilangad itself, with the survivor, till the trial of the rape case was over, especially considering their safety.

“The victim is actually living on the strength and support extended from our side. Our presence itself is a great solace for her, who is totally in a broken situation,” they said.

Alleging that the transfer orders were a “strategy” to put all of them under pressure, the nuns said, “If the transfer is effected, we will not be in a position to give evidence in the case daringly.”

“We will not be allowed to live peacefully and will collapse emotionally and mentally. Our lives will be in danger,” they said.

The protest led by the nuns and the Catholic reformist forums here in September last year had led to a public outrage and demands for action against the bishop.

Also read: Abuse, Cover-Ups and Silence: Why India’s Catholic Church Needs a Reformation

Bishop Mulakkal, a senior member of the Roman Catholic clergy in India, was arrested last year following allegations by the nun that he repeatedly raped and sexually assaulted her at the Kuravilangad convent between 2014 and 2016, a charge denied by him.

The 54-year-old clergyman was “temporarily” relieved of all pastoral responsibilities as the bishop of the Jalandhar diocese by the Vatican.

The congregation had issued the transfer orders of the nuns last year, much before the outbreak of protests, but they had then refused to accept those.

In a recent communique, Superior General Regina said it was a “matter of serious concern” for her to note that they were yet to join their convents assigned previously.

Four Nuns Shunted From Kerala Convent for Speaking Against Bishop Franco Mulakkal

In an effort likely meant to isolate the nuns further, four of the five protesting nuns have been asked to return to the convents they were previously assigned to by the Missionaries of Jesus.

New Delhi: For making their protest known against rape-accused Bishop Franco Mulakkal, head of the Jalandhar diocese of the Catholic Church, four nuns from Kuravilangad convent have been reportedly asked to leave immediately by Superior General Regina Kadamthottu.

According to an exclusive story by The News Minute, which gained access to the letters asking the nuns to leave the convent in Kerala’s Kottayam district, this is an effort to isolate and silence the nuns – the nuns have been asked to return to the convent they were previously assigned by the Missionaries of Jesus.

Also read: ‘Bishop Franco Mulakkal Is a Symptom of the Decay of the Church’

But though it was five nuns who took part in the protest in September 2018 organised by the Save Our Sisters (SOS) Action Council, only four have been asked to pack up and leave – Sister Alphy Pallasseril, Sister Anupama Kelamangalathuveliyil, Sister Josephine Villoonnickal, and Sister Ancitta Urumbil. The fifth participant, Sister Nina Rose, has not been directed to vacate.

“You have chosen in your individual capacity to support and pursue the legal battle seeking justice. The MJ Congregation and its members do not intend to make any sort of intervention or interference into the due process of law and justice and you will be free to carry on the judicial pursuit,” the letter accessed by The News Minute reads.

Also read: Abuse, Cover-Ups and Silence: Why India’s Catholic Church Needs a Reformation

Sister Anupama, who had led the protests against Bishop Franco, has been asked to return to Chamiyari community in Punjab; Sister Ancitta has been asked to join the Pariyaram community in Kannur; Sister Alphy has been asked to join the Pakartala community in Bihar; and Sister Josephine, who was appointed as Superior at Lalmatia community in Jharkhand, has also been asked to return, The News Minute reported.

The case

In her complaint to the Kottayam Police in June, a 43-year-old nun, also a mother superior, had alleged that Bishop Mulakkal raped her at a guest house in Kuravilangad in May 2014 and later sexually exploited her on several occasions. The nun said she had to approach the police as church authorities did not act on her repeated complaints against the clergyman.

In September, in fact, the Missionaries of Jesus congregation had alleged that the victim, who had accused the Mulakkal of raping her, five nuns and four others, plotted against the Bishop to frame him in the Kerala rape case. The congregation had also earlier alleged that the Kerala nun had “questionable relations with a local taxi driver” and “a physical relationship with a relative’s husband”.

Later, the senior Catholic priest was interrogated by the Kerala Special Investigation Team (SIT). In a strongly-worded letter, the nun had urged the Vatican to intervene in the matter and to remove Mulakkal as the head of Jalandhar diocese. Following this, the Bishop had been temporarily relieved of his pastoral reponsibilities. Soon after, the bishop was arrested by the Kerala police after intense interrogation and taken to a guest house at Kuravilangadu by police for reconstruction of the crime scene.

Bishop Franco Mulakkal. Credit: PTI

Mulakkal, was granted bail on October 15, 2018. Upon his release, he described his time inside prison as a “21-day retreat” where he got time for “meditation and personal reflection”.

When he returned to Jalandhar on October 18, he was given a ‘grand’ welcome by the Diocese of Jalandhar, including the nuns.

After the death of one of the key witnesses in the case, Father Kuriakose Kattuthara in Punjab’s Jalandhar in September, security was stepped up for the victim. His brother, Jose Kattuthara, has alleged that Father Kattuthara had been killed for giving a statement against Bishop Franco Mulakkal.

Before his death, in an interview to Mathrubhumi, the Father had said he was constantly threatened by church officials for his support of the nun who has accused the bishop of rape.

In November, the Missionaries of Jesus Congregation asked the Kerala police to shift the nun and five witnesses to a government-run home as the convent did not have financial resources to ensure their protection.

“Accusations sans truth have been flying thick and fast in the public realm about the lack of concern the MJ Congregation was showing to the nuns who are standing for justice. Even as you and a few other MJ members continue to have no qualms in issuing malafied public statements and circulate baseless stories tarnishing the images of the MJ congregation and portraying the Mother General and other members as ‘enemies of those who are fighting for their justice’, I have been ensuring that the congregation continue supporting you all with food, accommodation and the cost of medical treatment as required,” the letter evicting the nuns reads.

Nun Who Accused Bishop Mulakkal of Sexual Assault Heckled at Kattuthara’s Funeral

Reacting to the incident, Sister Anupama, who was accompanied by other nuns, broke down and said she was “deeply hurt”.

New Delhi: Sister Anupama, who was at the forefront of protests demanding the arrest of Bishop Franco Mulakkal, who was accused of raping a nun, was heckled and asked by some people to leave the cemetery where the funeral of a key witness in the rape case was going on on Thursday.

Kuriakose Kattuthara, a priest who had also testified against Mulakkal, was found dead under mysterious circumstances in Dasuya near Jalandhar in northern Punjab three days ago. The post-mortem was held at Jalandhar and his body was brought to Kerala on Wednesday.

At the funeral this evening, a section of the faithful protested Sister Anupama’s presence and asked her to leave the cemetery at St Mary’s church in Pallipuram. Reacting to the incident, Sister Anupama, who was accompanied by other nuns, broke down and said she was “deeply hurt” by the protests.

“I am from this place. I know Father Kattuthara for many years. He has seen me as his own daughter.. we have only stood for truth,” she said.

Also read: ‘Bishop Franco Mulakkal Is a Symptom of the Decay of the Church’

Father Kattuthara’s mysterious death comes days after Mulakkal, who was arrested and is presently out on bail, reached Jalandhar from Kerala. Mulakkal, who was granted conditional bail on October 15, received a rousing welcome from his followers and supporters when he returned to Jalandhar.

In her complaint to the Kottayam Police in June, Sister Anupama alleged that Mulakkal raped her at a guest house in Kuravilangad in May 2014 and later sexually exploited her on several occasions.

Mulakkal denied the charges as “baseless and concocted,” insisting she levelled those as the Catholic order had rejected her demand for favours.

(PTI)