Man Held for Sending Threatening Messages To Goa CM, Other Politicians

Ashish Naik, who lives at Sancoale village in South Goa, was arrested by the Ponda police, more than a week after Sawant lodged a complaint about getting threatening texts.

Panaji: Police on Monday arrested a 25-year-old man for allegedly sending threatening messages to Goa Chief Minister Pramod Sawant and other leaders, and also demanding money from them, an official said.

Ashish Naik, who resides at Sancoale village in South Goa, was arrested by the Ponda police, more than a week after Sawant lodged a complaint about getting threatening and abusive text messages from an international number, he said.

Police Inspector Mohan Gaude claimed the accused has confessed to sending threatening messages to several well-known people, including the chief minister, and seeking money from them.

Explaining modus operandi, Gaude said Naik used to send messages from an international number in which use to mention a local mobile number that belonged to a man with whom he had personal enmity.

Sawant had filed the complaint with the Panaji police on November 5, 2020, against an unidentified person for sending him threatening messages and asking for money.

Goa Forward Party vice-president Durgadas Kamat on November 7, 2020, had filed a complaint with the Ponda police station about receiving threatening messages.

Former BJP leader Pranav Sanvordekar, too, had filed a similar complaint with the Curchorem Police.

Book Review: The Mythmaking Around Parrikar’s Life Hid Many Compromises

A new biography of the Goan politician, who had a cult following but was obsessed with holding on to power, has something for both his admirers and disparagers.

Manohar Parrikar enjoyed something of a cult following within the BJP in Goa but also had his share of critics. These grew exponentially in his last term in power, when he failed to live up to his much-hyped promises. A recently released political biography of the former Goa chief minister, who also served as Union defence minister, has something for both his admirers and disparagers. But it fails to substantially analyse and contextualise the rise and legacy of a politician who was so hung up on power that he clung on as chief minister to his dying day at great cost to Goa and the democratic process of government.

“In 2005, he told me the feeling of losing power was as painful as someone trying to rip off one’s skin. He even said that he finally realized why Congress leaders would feel restless without power,” one of Parrikar’s confidants and RSS man Ratnakar Lele is quoted as saying. Whether the decision to not step down came from a profound sense of loyalty to the BJP – to ensure the party’s untrustworthy allies wouldn’t conspire to form an alternative with the Congress – or because of his abiding belief that only he had what it took to govern Goa, the authors fail to explore.

Sadguru Patil and Mayabhushan Nagvenkar
An Extraordinary Life: A Biography of Manohar Parrikar
Penguin (July 2020)

Written by Goa-based journalists Sadguru Patil and Mayabhushan Nagvenkar, An Extraordinary Life: A Biography of Manohar Parrikar (Penguin Random House India) released a little after a year since Parrikar died from pancreatic cancer aged 63, tracks the life and political trajectory of the BJP politician from his childhood in small-town Mapusa—where his father ran a grocery store—through his years at IIT Bombay, his political baptism via the RSS and his eventual rise to power. There’s even a chapter on his quirky food habits.

The authors say:

“Dedicating a chapter about food and other habits may appear to be slightly incongruous in a political biography of a former defence minister and a politician who went on to define an entire political era for Goa. But his maverick personality, marked with oddities, charm and human flaws, went a long way into the making of his aura, which along with his sharp political acumen, carried him far.” (Emphasis added)

They claim, “By virtue of rank, Parrikar became the state’s tallest politician ever, with his appointment as defence minister in 2014. Veteran Goan politicians like Ramakant Khalap of the MGP [Maharashtrawadi Gomantak Party], Eduardo Faleiro from the Congress and BJP’s Shripad Naik have served as Union ministers of state, but none could pass the vertical barrier to become a full-fledged cabinet minister.”

Parrikar came into electoral politics in 1994 with the BJP’s debut in the state assembly. An early ambition to move to parliament was nixed with his 1996 defeat. The RSS’s astute and hard-nosed deal brokering with the MGP (which eventually emasculated the regional party to a has-been) helped the BJP and also Parrikar grow in Goa.

Even if unintended, the book does a harsh takedown of Parrikar in some passages: “His tenure in power, especially the later phases, was marked with some of the most brazen betrayals of promises and an administration that at best ranged from average to below par.” The sweeping assertions and liberal use of superlatives (the “extraordinary” in the title for instance) play into the BJP’s agenda of writing out the past to plug its new icons. (Invincible a pictorial tribute to Parrikar as “India’s most beloved Defence Minister”, was released by the Centre on his first death anniversary this March. The Goa government too has commissioned a journalist who was close to Parrikar to produce an official biography for a fee of Rs 10 lakh.)

As defence minister, Parrikar tried to insidiously erase Nehru’s role in liberating Goa by projecting only the armed forces, ignoring the many years of diplomacy between India, Portugal and the UN that preceded the 1961 action. With patience running out, Nehru defied the US to order military action which was launched on December 17 of 1961 and wrapped up in two days after Goa’s takeover.

“Although Parrikar insisted on returning to Goa for purely political and personal reasons, he would often raise the emotional, patriotic pitch with his trademark refrain that he returned to his home state after paying a debt to the Indian Armed Forces—by serving as the defence minister… ‘The Indian Army liberated the state. I think that was a debt that needed to be paid back,’” the book says, using a quote from 2018.

His successor, Pramod Sawant, Goa’s current chief minister, who was recently ticked off by governor Satya Pal Malik for his ‘botched handling’ of the coronavirus crisis, has sung a similar refrain blaming Nehru for “delaying” Goa’s annexation.

Quoting Lele again, the account claims as defence minister, Parrikar had differences with Arun Jaitley. “He never mentioned it publicly, but Parrikar often told me how Jaitley was delaying the resolution of the OROP (one rank, one pension) issue.” With Jaitley’s demise, there’s no way of sifting the chaff from the truth of these claims.

Seen through the narrow prism of family and the inner coterie of confidants and advisors (one of them a discredited former state advocate general), the biography offers an intimate account of the former chief minister’s personal life and a meandering one of his political journey. Missing, however, are the views of his critics and the few who dared stand up to him within the party. The former chief minister Laxmikant Parsekar and Union minister Shripad Naik, for instance, had openly rooted for Parrikar to step down more than six months before his passing away because of his debilitating health condition.

Laxmkant Parsekar. Photo: PTI

After an election victory in 2002, Parrikar was asked by a national magazine if he was an RSS man or a chief minister first. ‘Why can’t one be both?’ he responded. “I am a staunch RSS man and that’s why I’m not communal. What I have learnt from the RSS is to maintain justice. The RSS never taught me to be communal.” The question was perceptive, given Goa’s religious demographic composition and the initial aversion of the minorities to the saffron party.

If you’re looking for answers to Parrikar’s ambivalence on minorities and whether deep down, he did subscribe to the RSS view of a Hindu rashtra, you’re unlikely to find them in this book which deals with his RSS roots and his organising groups of karsevaks from Goa to Ayodhya (1990 and December 1992 when his mother went along) like they were taking a walk in the park.

In some elections, Parrikar went all out to polarise the vote, in others he desperately wooed the Catholics to breach the halfway mark, which the BJP managed for the first time in 2012. This was not as a result of his “social engineering skills” (another media created “urban legend”) alone, but a coalescing of a complex set of factors – an anti-Congress wave, a large infusion of funds (the casinos knew where to place their bets) and unprecedented media management that amplified the Congress’s warts and corruption. The sea of glum faces in the media section as the results flashed the BJP’s defeat in the next assembly election in 2017 said it all.

Parrikar “had promised to ban offshore casinos once in power…however, the Parrikar-led administration did not just allow much larger offshore casinos to replace the smaller casino vessels, but also did not move to appoint a regulatory mechanism like a Gaming Commissioner to ensure fair practices on the casino gaming floors,” the book says of his “legacy of U-turns” on casinos and mining. All this had been widely reported in the media.

Parrikar was indeed a leader of consequence in Goa. In the sea of faceless politicians that surrounded him within the BJP, he stood apart (the book calls him “the alpha” of the BJP). Driven by the singular ambition to make it to the top, his grassroots charisma and astute political leadership promoted the saffron party’s rise in Goa. A chapter on post-colonial politics would have given the book some depth and context. Where does his legacy stand for instance in contrast to the MGP’s golden age under Dayanand Bandodkar, or the chaotic years of Congress hegemony in Goa? Did the BJP bring any significant development in Goa (hundreds of government primary schools have shut down in recent years)? Just a recall of political developments of the last two decades is no substitute for critical analysis.

To those who’d written off the BJP in Goa after Parrikar, the saffron party’s proved it has not only survived but is thriving, one of the authors said in an online chat at the book’s launch in Panaji. The party has currently more Congressmen than those originally from the BJP in its legislature wing and a chief minister who can barely rule. The makings of several little rebellions, Congress style, are brewing within the Goa unit, one of them spurred by Parrikar’s son Utpal, who said people his father had brought into the party are being currently sidelined. Parrikar’s eventful political journey seems to be taking us right back to where it all began. A party looking more and more like the one it promised to replace.

Petition Filed Against Construction of Parrikar Memorial on Goa’s Miramar Beach

The petitioner, Devika Sequeira, told The Wire that the city shoreline was a part the “ecological heritage” and that politicians were making a sudden claim on this “public heritage”.

New Delhi: A petition has been filed in the Bombay high court at Goa seeking to direct the government to stop construction of a memorial for former chief minister Manohar Parrikar on Miramar beach in Panaji.

Manohar Parrikar, a four-time chief minister from Goa and former Union defence minister, passed away on March 17, 2019, after a prolonged battle with pancreatic cancer and was accorded a state funeral the next day.

Parrikar was later posthumously awarded the Padma Bhushan in January 2020.

The petition, filed by journalist Devika Sequeira, has said that the public beach “cannot be mismanaged, misused or appropriated for constructing a memorial by causing harm and damage,” According to a TOI report, the petition also said, “The memorial will destroy the public beach in terms of the findings of the one-man committee headed by Nandkumar Kamat, constituted by Parrikar.”

The committee had been appointed by the state in 2001 following a proposal to privatise Miramar beach.

The petition has sought an immediate halt to the construction of the memorial until the committee’s findings and recommendations are considered. The petition has also sought protection for beaches from any construction, including memorials.

Also read: Goa Govt Corners Chunk of ‘No Development’ Beach for Rs 8.5-Crore ‘Shrine’ to Parrikar

Speaking to The Wire, Sequeira said that as a journalist, it would be a conflict of interest for her to write and report on the case henceforth. “But as a citizen and someone who has been born and lived in this city almost my entire life I feel very strongly about the government’s decision to build another memorial on Miramar beach,” she said.

Sequeira said that was compelled to file a case after nobody else came forward to challenge the matter in court. “Unfortunately, we live in the age of supine and self-serving politicians. Not one of them – not even the MLA of Panjim or the environment minister to whom I appealed several times – dared question such a unilateral decision,” she said.

Underscoring the public’s collective right over the beach, Sequeira said, “The city shoreline is a part of our ecological heritage, and all of a sudden politicians who have no attachment to it are making a claim on this public heritage”.

Sequeira’s lawyer Rohit Bras De Sa told The Wire that the matter would come up for admission after the relaxation of the coronavirus notification by the high court. “The state through the attorney general is on private notice and appeared before the court yesterday. The hearing was deferred for the aforementioned reason,” he said.

The foundation stone for Parrikar’s memorial, which is expected to cost close to Rs 7.8-crore, was laid on the former chief minister’s 64th birth anniversary on December 13.

Miramar beach is classified as CRZ III under the coastal regulation laws. Environmentalists say no construction is allowed in such zones up to 200 metres of the high tide line (HTL), which pretty much includes the whole stretch of beach.

Goa’s BJP-led government intends to commemorate Parrikar’s first death anniversary on Tuesday with a series of programmes that are on track despite advisories against ‘mass gatherings’ in view of the coronavirus outbreak.

Tarun Tejpal Case Adjourned Till October 21

The complainant who accused the Tehelka magazine editor of sexual assault did not attend the hearing.

Panaji: A Goa court on Monday adjourned till October 21 the trial against Tehelka magazine founder Tarun Tejpal in a sexual assault case lodged by a former colleague, after the complainant failed to attend the hearing.

The additional district and sessions court at Mapusa will continue hearing on October 21, 22 and 23, when the victim would be cross-examined by Tejpal’s counsel, special public prosecutor Francisco Tavora told reporters.

A Supreme Court bench in August asked the Goa court to complete the trial in the case, preferably within six months, and refused Tejpal’s plea to quash the First Information Report (FIR) filed against him.

Tejpal allegedly sexually assaulted the complainant inside an elevator of a five-star hotel in Goa in 2013.

He has denied the allegations levelled against him.

Also Read: Don’t Judges Need the Trust of People More Than People Need to Trust Judges?

Tejpal was arrested on November 30, 2013 by the crime branch after his anticipatory bail plea was rejected by the court.

He has been out on bail since May 2014.

In September last year, the district court framed charges against Tejpal.

He was booked under various Indian Penal Code (IPC) sections including wrongful restraint, criminal force and rape. He had earlier also moved the Bombay high court, seeking a stay on framing of charges against him, but his petition was dismissed.

Environment Ministry’s Quest for Blue Flags Will Displace Fishers from Beaches

Geography 101: beaches don’t exist in a vacuum.

The Foundation for Environmental Education in Denmark began offering coastal properties around the world its ‘blue flag’ certification 1985, starting with France. The blue flag is recognised as one of the world’s more prestigious ecolabels for beaches, marinas and tourism operators. According to the official website, there are more than 45 countries on the blue-flag map covering over 4,000 beaches in Europe (Spain has the most blue-flag beaches, 570+).

The foundation evaluates beaches according to their water quality, environmental management, environmental education and safety.

The Society for Integrated Coastal Management (SICOM) – under the Integrated Coastal Area Management Programme – is responsible for getting Indian beaches the blue-flag accreditation. Pursuant to this, the Union environment ministry asked the states and union territories to identify at least 10 beaches each and submit the list by September 30, 2019.

Privatising blue flag sites

In 2002, Nandkumar Kamat presented a report to Manohar Parrikar, then the chief minister of Goa, in which Kamat advised against the privatisation of beaches. However, Panaji’s Miramar beach is due to be privatised as soon as it receives its blue-flag credentials.

The foundation accepts applications from “any authority charged with responsibility for the beach” as long as the beach has a “legal bathing area” and other attendant facilities. The manual also says “it is preferable that beach users be granted free access to a blue-flag beach” but also recognises that “at some beaches, e.g. private beaches, members of the public are charged a small, reasonable fee to access the beach”.

Herein lies the rub. The manual doesn’t say what a ‘reasonable fee’ could be, how it is to be determined and who should. In fact, the manual generally ignores the fact that beaches often don’t exist in a vacuum.

The Bharat Mukti Morcha’s Goa unit has appealed to the government to spare Miramar beach from the accreditation – and subsequent privatisation – because the livelihood of thousands of small-scale fishermen depend on the offshore waters. As with the pricing, the accreditation manual states that “the fishing in these areas will follow certain rules and regulations” but doesn’t explain what these rules are.

The logo of the 'blue flag' accreditation flies as a flag in Hrvatska, Croatia. Photo: Roberta F./Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

The logo of the ‘blue flag’ accreditation flies as a flag in Hrvatska, Croatia. Photo: Roberta F./Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Such ambiguity effectively vests private companies and organisations with the power to decide what fees to charge and how much fishing to allow. When the manual does make a constructive suggestion, it is interpreted in a way that ignores the suggestion.

For example, the document states that stakeholders will have to decide how a beach is managed. But in the case of the Padubidri beach in Udupi, Karnataka, a blue-flag site, the government has transferred the contract to a private entity in Gurgaon. This entity has said the accreditation “will give international standards to the beach, and the communities near the beach will be given jobs, which will further enhance the economy”.

However, until the blue-flag question came along, most fishing communities in the area – which caught their fish from the Kamini river and the sea – didn’t have reason to consider changing jobs. But if the beach is privatised and they’re kept out they might be forced to take up small jobs on the jetty.

Aside from the foundation’s prescriptions, the environment ministry also hasn’t said anything about if and how fishing communities will be rehabilitated. Most of the sites for which the ministry is eyeing the accreditation are near fishing villages, so tourism won’t be possible unless these people are displaced.

Environmental education in practice

Moreover, the area including and around Padubidri beach is ecologically sensitive because this is where the Kamini flows into the Arabian sea. Admitting tourists into such a space will also require felling some trees, laying roads, making way for cars to pass through, setting up lodging facilities, etc. – all of which are in opposition to the ‘environmental education’ part of the blue-flag accreditation’s values.

Indeed, the ministry as well as private contractors also seem to be ignoring the requirement that “industrial, waste-water or sewage-related discharges must not affect the beach area”. Additionally, this also seems to suggest that the foundation is prepared to award the blue flag mark to a beach as long as the beach alone is left untouched.

Governments at the Centre as well as in some states have been rapidly weakening coastal zone regulations, and typify the country’s eagerness at the moment to unlock these areas for real estate and tourism. A notification issued in 2018 changed these rules to allow ecotourism activities in CRZ-I areas – i.e. the most ecologically sensitive areas, including mangroves, coral reefs, sand dunes and intertidal zones. The rush to have the country’s beaches given the blue-flag tag will only worsen this national crisis, unfolding as it is along with the international climate crisis.

Rituja Mitra is pursuing an MA in Development at the Azim Premji University, Bengaluru.

With Heavy Rainfall, Several Parts of Western India Flooded

Continuous rain in parts of Maharashtra, Goa, and Karnataka has led to casualties and people being stranded.

New Delhi: Incessant rains in Maharashtra’s Kolhapur district caused flooding in several low-lying areas on Tuesday, following which 10,000 people were evacuated and power supply to over 85,000 consumers was suspended, officials said.

Several parts of Karnataka and Goa were also flooded, with reports of people being stranded and rivers overflowing reported from many areas of the three western states.

The national highway between south Kolhapur and Belgaum in Karnataka was shut for vehicular traffic due to water-logging in the area, Kolhapur Superintendent of Police Abhinav Deshmukh told PTI.

“On Monday, we closed one side of the national highway. However, as rains increased, we had to shut the entire national highway in the early hours of Tuesday,” he said.

Kolhapur has been witnessing “unprecedented” rains, causing a flood-like situation in several tehsils, he said.

“On Monday, we shifted more than 4,500 people from low-lying areas, and today, over 6,000 people have been evacuated from several villages,” Deshmukh said.

Power supply to around 85,523 consumers was temporarily suspended as a precautionary measure, an official from the Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company (MSEDCL) said.

Teams of the National Disaster Response Force (NDRF), fire brigade, local administration and police have been roped in for help as some rivers in the district are flowing above the danger mark, Deshmukh said.

“An Army column (comprising around 60 personnel) has been summoned from Pune. They are likely to join the rescue operation in the district soon,” he added.

The district administration has also sought help from the Navy in the rescue operations, another official said.

An official at the collectorate said the situation this time was worse than 2005, when heavy rains pounded Mumbai and other areas of western Maharashtra.

Also read: Maharashtra Rains Leave Two Dead, Hundreds Stranded

The water level of the Panchganga river in Kolhapur crossed the danger mark of 49 feet. “It was flowing at 52 feet level on Tuesday,” he said.

Due to incessant rains in western Maharashtra, the district administrations of Pune, Satara, Kolhapur and Sangli declared a holiday for schools and colleges on Tuesday, sources said.

Some parts of Satara and Sangli were also flooded as the water level of the Krishna river rose following heavy rains, another official said.

Several thousand cusecs (cubic foot per second) of water was being released from Koyna and Radhanagari dams, leading to rise in the water levels of the Krishna and Panchganga rivers, respectively, he said.

The Krishna river further flows into north Karnataka where the Almatti dam is built over it.

The water resources departments of both Maharashtra and Karnataka have in joint coordination increased the release of water from Almatti to 3 lakh cusecs to ease the situation, he added.

One dead in Karnataka

One person was killed, while schools were shut and bus and train services cancelled in parts of several districts of Karnataka as the flood situation worsened in the southern state on Tuesday.

Belagavi bore the brunt as water from the Koyna dam in neighbouring Maharashtra gushed into the Krishna river.

According to police, a 25-year-old man was killed at Hoskote in Bylahongal taluk of Belagavi district when the wall of his house crashed on him.

Besides the Krishna river, the Markandeya, Ghataprabha, Malaprabha and Bheema rivers are in spate, wreaking havoc in many parts of the state.

Water from the Markandeya river gushed into Gokak and Hukkeri in Belagavi, reports said.

The districts hit due to the torrential rains and subsequent flooding are Belagavi, Vijayapura, Yadgiri, Raichur, Bagalkot, Hubballi-Dharwad, Shivamogga, Kodagu and Uttara Kannada.

Aerial view of flooded parts of northern Karnataka. Photo: PTI

Several people stranded in Goa

Several people were stranded at Diwar Island near Panaji due to flooding in the area following incessant rains in Goa.

Besides, eight passenger buses were stuck on the state’s border with Karnataka due to the heavy rains which inundated several low-lying areas, officials said.

Local resident Manohar Bhomkar, 70, who was stranded at the Diwar Island, posted a video on social media of some water-logged homes on the island, following which state water resources minister Filipe Neri Rodrigues said the government would provide all help to them.

The exact number of those stranded at the island was not immediately known.

In the video, Bhomkar said due to breach in the embankment of a nearby river, water gushed into their homes.

“There is flood everywhere. The embankment has breached and water is entering the island from all sides. We have been stranded for four days,” he said in the video.

Rodrigues said the government was making all efforts to help those stuck due to flooding at various places.

“We will also provide assistance to people at Diwar Island,” he said.

The island is located across the Mandovi river near Panaji and its residents have to use boats to reach the state capital and other places.

However, following heavy showers, the state river navigation department suspended the ferry service to some places, including Diwar Island.

The coastal state has been receiving heavy showers for the last one week, throwing normal life out of gear.

Around eight buses carrying several passengers, including students, were stuck on the Goa-Karnataka border since Monday night due to flooding in the area after heavy rains, an official in the Chief Minister’s Office (CMO) said.

Chief minister Pramod Sawant instructed the officials concerned to rush to Radhanagari village on the state border with Karnataka to rescue the stranded passengers, he said.

“Our teams have rushed to the spot with water and food for the stranded passengers,” the official added.

Earlier, around ten people stranded at their water-logged homes in Pilgaon village of North Goa district were rescued by personnel of the disaster management department on Monday night.

Several families were also evacuated from some villages in Bicholim taluka where homes were inundated following the heavy downpour, he said.

Besides, around 15 families stranded due to flooding at their homes in Usgao village were also rescued on Tuesday afternoon, he said.

Also read: Deficit Rainfall Puts Manipur in Drought-Like Situation, Govt Writes to Centre

In the morning, Sawant conducted an inspection of some flooded villages in low-lying areas of North Goa and parts of the state capital Panaji to assess the situation.

The chief minister said he would be meeting officials of the education department later in the day to check the monsoon forecast for Wednesday. “If a similar situation is likely to continue, the education department will announce a holiday for primary and secondary schools in the state on Wednesday,” he told reporters.

The Mandovi river in the state crossed the danger mark on Monday night, causing flooding in some villages of Sattari taluka in North Goa, another official said.

Besides, Sonal village in Sattari was cut-off from other parts of the district after heavy downpour in the area, he added.

The weather department has forecast heavy to very heavy rainfall in both North Goa and South Goa districts in next 24 hours and issued an ‘orange alert’.

It has predicted strong winds with speed reaching 45-50 km per hour and gusting up to 65 kmph along the Maharashtra-Goa coast.

Fishermen have been advised not to venture into the sea due to the rough weather, though the fisheries department lifted the ban on fishing in the state from August 1.

Panaji By-Polls: Election Watchdog Finds Discrepancies in Affidavits Filed by AAP, Congress Candidates

The Panaji Assembly by-poll was necessitated due to the death of sitting MLA, Manohar Parrikar on March 17.

Panaji: An election watchdog has pointed out discrepancies in the income tax details submitted by the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) and Congress candidates in their nominations for the Panaji Assembly by-poll in Goa.

In a release issued on Tuesday, the Association of Democratic Reforms (ADR) said that the affidavits filed by AAP nominee Valmiki Naik for the 2017 state Assembly elections and the upcoming by-poll show a difference of over Rs 1 lakh in his IT returns for the financial year 2015-16.

In his affidavit for the Panaji by-poll, Naik has shown his IT returns as Rs 3,91,341 for 2015-16, while in his 2017 submission, he mentioned a figure of Rs 2,89,810 for the same period, ADR said.

It also pointed out that Congress candidate Atanasio Monserratte in his affidavit for the upcoming by-poll has mentioned his IT returns for 2015-16 as Rs 24,50,076, which is Rs 34,746 less than the Rs 24,84,822 figure submitted by him in his 2017 Assembly election affidavit.

Also Read: In 2019, Is BJP Riding a Modi Wave or a Money Wave?

While comparing his 2017 and 2019 affidavits, though Monserratte’s net worth went down by about Rs 9 crore in last two years, he declared Rs 1,69,84,756 as his IT returns for 2017-18 and Rs 33,33,822 cash in hand each (self and spouse) on the date of filing nomination on April 29, the ADR said.

When contacted, North Goa’s district election officer R. Menaka said she will look into the matter.

Naik and Monserratte could not be contacted for their response to ADR’s findings.

In the 2017 Assembly polls, BJP leader Siddharth Kunkolienkar won the Panaji seat located in North Goa district, while Monserratte, who then contested as an Independent, stood second, and Naik came third.

Kunkolienkar vacated the seat later that year to allow then chief minister Manohar Parrikar to contest and enter the 40-member Goa Assembly.

The Panaji Assembly by-poll was necessitated due to the death of sitting MLA Parrikar on March 17.

The BJP has nominated Kunkolienkar to take on Monserratte, who is now contesting on Congress’ ticket and Naik in the by-poll to be held May 19.

Manohar Parrikar Wanted to Resign as CM, BJP High Command Said No: Goa Minister

Parrikar, 62, has been recuperating at his residence here since he was discharged from the All India Institute of Medical Sciences in Delhi on October 14. He is suffering from a pancreatic ailment.

Panaji: Goa Forward Party chief and agriculture minister Vijai Sardesai suggested on Thursday that the ailing chief minister Manohar Parrikar wanted to resign, but the BJP high command vetoed it.

“He wanted to give up the CM’s post altogether. He had even shown an inclination to give away his portfolios (to other ministers) when he was admitted to a hospital during Ganesh Chaturthi festival,” Sardesai said here.

“But then several things happened. BJP high command stepped in….it (to resign or not) is not in his (Parrikar’s) hands entirely,” Sardesai told reporters.

Parrikar, 62, has been recuperating at his residence here since he was discharged from the All India Institute of Medical Sciences in Delhi on October 14. He is suffering from pancreatic cancer.

Also read: Without Manohar Parrikar, BJP Stares at Bleak Future in Goa

Asked about independent MLA and Revenue Minister Rohan Khaunte’s remark that the administration has become sluggish in Parrikar’s absence, Sardesai said, “I have always been saying that CM’s ill-health has had some sort of impact, and it is showing.”

To a question on another alliance partner Maharashtrawadi Gomantak Party (MGP) filing a petition against two former Congress MLAs who joined the BJP, the minister said it was surprising.

MGP has moved the Goa Bench of Bombay high court, seeking to disqualify Subhash Shirodkar and Dayanand Sopte, former Congress MLAs who recently joined the BJP.

“It is a matter between two constituents of the alliance – BJP and MGP. So we are not concerned with it,” Sardesai said.

“As far as MGP is concerned, its decision to go to the court is surprising….I can believe it is a preemptive move, they (MGP) have not lost anything, Congress has lost two MLAs,” Sardesai said in a cryptic remark.

Speculation was rife earlier that MGP MLAs might join the BJP which does not have a majority on its own in Goa Assembly.

BJP spokespersons were not available for comment on Sardesai’s remarks.

Congress Asks Goa Governor for a Special Session to Prove BJP’s Majority

The Congress called it a “classic case of fraud” being played on the people of Goa by the Centre.

Panaji: The Congress demanded on Saturday that Goa governor Mridula Sinha summon a special session of the legislative assembly and ask the BJP-led coalition government to prove its majority.

The Congress has been claiming that the state government is in disarray in the absence of chief minister Manohar Parrikar from office on account of medical reasons.

Also Read: With No Second-Rung Leadership, Parrikar’s Ill Health Sends BJP Scrambling in Goa

Addressing reporters in Panaji, Congress chief spokesperson Randeep Singh Surjewala said the party would raise this issue during the upcoming winter session of Parliament and also before President Ram Nath Kovind.

The Congress had submitted representations to the president and the Goa governor, claiming that the party had the requisite number of MLAs to prove majority in the 40-member House.

“Goa is a classic case of fraud being played on the people of Goa by the governor and the BJP at Centre,” Surjewala said.

“We will put pressure on the central leadership of the BJP in the winter session and also before the president for our demand to summon a special session to prove majority,” he said.

Accusing the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party in Goa of holding the Constitution “captive”, Surjewala said the formation of the Cabinet Advisory Committee by the BJP in absence of Parrikar is a “blatant fraud on the Constitution”.

Also Read: Goa Agriculture Minister Says Parrikar’s Ailment Affecting State’s Administration

The BJP-led state government is supported by the Goa Forward Party, the Maharashtravadi Gomantak Party and three Independent MLAs.