Tag: normalisation

India Welcomes ‘Normalisation’ of Israel-UAE Ties, Reiterates Support for ‘Palestinian Cause’

The Palestinian leadership were quick to condemn the agreement as a “betrayal”, with Palestine president Mahmoud Abbas recalling the ambassador to UAE.

New Delhi: A day after US President Donald Trump made the surprise announcement, India has welcomed the ‘full normalisation’ of ties between Israel and the United Arab Emirates, an agreement brokered by in exchange for Tel Aviv suspending its annexation of Palestinian territories.

On Thursday, the White House released a joint statement signed by the three countries, which stated that Gulf kingdom will work towards establishing diplomatic links with Israel. Due to this “diplomatic breakthrough”, Israel has agreed to “suspend” Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s plan to declare sovereignty over West Bank.

In the press briefing, Trump described the agreement as a “truly historic moment”, comparing it to the 1994 Israel-Jordan peace treaty. Once the pact is implemented, UAE will become the third Arab country to recognise Israel, after Egypt and Jordan.

UAE foreign minister Abdullah bin Zayed Al Nahyan called India’s external affairs minister S. Jaishankar on Friday afternoon to brief him about the new deal with Israel.

Also read: ‘A Betrayal’: Israel-UAE Deal Leaves Palestinians Surprised, Dismayed

Articulating India’s position, MEA spokesperson Anurag Srivastava said, “India has consistently supported peace, stability and development in West Asia, which is its extended neighbourhood. In that context, we welcome the full normalisation of ties between UAE and Israel. Both nations are key strategic partners of India”.

He added that India continued with its “traditional support for the Palestinian cause”. “We hope to see early resumption of direct negotiations to find an acceptable two-state solution,” said Srivastava.

The Palestinian leadership were quick to condemn the agreement as a “betrayal”, with Palestine president Mahmoud Abbas recalling the ambassador to UAE.

“The Palestinian leadership considers this step to blow up the Arab Peace Initiative and the decisions of the Arab and Islamic summits, and international legitimacy, as an aggression against the Palestinian people, and as neglecting Palestinian rights and sacred things, especially Jerusalem and the independent Palestinian state on the borders of June 4, 1967,” said the statement, which called on Arab League to denounce the pact.

India’s statement on the agreement is not surprising as all the three nations signing the statement have become close partners of the Modi government.

When contacted, there was no response from the Palestine embassy in New Delhi to India, on the agreement.

Deal not entirely a ‘surprise’

Retired Indian foreign service officer Navdeep Suri, who had been India’s ambassador to UAE till September 2019, told The Wire that the trends towards the normalisation of ties between Israel and UAE had been clearly discernible in the last couple of years. The two countries were “driven by their joint antipathy towards Iran,” Suri said.

In July 2015, Iran and a group of six nations led by the US reached a deal to limit Iran’s nuclear weapons programme in exchange for lifting of economic sanctions. Five months later, Israel was opening its first ever diplomatic mission in a Gulf nation, with a representative posted at the Abu Dhabi headquarters of International Renewable Energy Agency. At that time, Israel had claimed that this was neither a consulate nor a mission, but the presence of an Israeli diplomat in UAE gave out an unmistakable signal.

Suri also recalled the visit of the Israel sports minister Miri Regev in October 2018, ostensibly to attend a judo tournament. She visited the Grand Mosque in Abu Dhabi and wrote in the guest book in Hebrew. “The fact that Emirati media was covering her visit and publishing her photographs indicated that the rapprochement was in the offing,” he said.

There were more signs of active Arab-Israeli backchannel links, with Emirati officials publicly laying ground of an imminent change.

“Many, many years ago, when there was an Arab decision not to have contact with Israel, that was a very, very wrong decision, looking back,” UAE minister of state for foreign affairs Anwar Gargash told Abu Dhabi based daily The National in March 2019.

He forecast, according to the newspaper report, a “strategic shift” in relations between Israel and Arab nations.

Despite the clear willingness of Emirati leadership, it took more than a year for UAE to formalise its already extensive links with Israel.

Role of US election

The timing, believes Suri, was clearly due to the forthcoming presidential election in November. “Both Israel and the Emiratis want to help Trump politically. They want him back in the White House,” he said

UAE’s aversion of the previous Barack Obama administration had been publicly articulated after Trump’s surprising win in 2016. In remarks published in the official news agency in November 2016, Gargash described the Obama administration’s tenure as “eight years of weakened American engagement in the region, which many feel has created a disconcerting vacuum”.

Even if Trump loses the elections, UAE is not likely to face any major diplomatic repercussions. The Democratic presidential candidate, Joe Biden, who had been vice-president in the Obama administration, welcomed the agreement as a “historic step to bridge the deep divides of the Middle East”.

Meanwhile, Trump with an eye at branding the agreement as a diplomatic victory in the election campaign, stated that the pact will be called “Abraham accord” as Abraham was “father of all three great faiths”.

U.S. President Donald Trump receives applause after announcing that Israel and the United Arab Emirates have reached a peace deal that will lead to full normalization of diplomatic relations between the two Middle Eastern nations in an agreement that Trump helped broker, at White House in Washington, U.S., August 13, 2020. Photo: Reuters/Kevin Lamarque

West Asian reaction

In West Asia, all the Arab countries, except for Saudi Arabia, swiftly welcomed the agreement. Oman, which hosted Netanyahu on an official visit in 2018, backed UAE’s initiative to normalise ties with Israel, with Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi also tweeting his appreciation.

On the other side of the aisle, Iran described the deal as an act of “strategic stupidity”.

Joining Tehran, Turkey stated that “history and the conscience of the region’s peoples will not forget and never forgive this hypocritical behaviour of the UAE, betraying the Palestinian cause for the sake of its narrow interests”. Turkish president Tayyip Erdogan said that he was considering snapping ties with UAE.

However, Saudi Arabia, which had led the Arab world against Iran, remained conspicuously silent, largely reflecting the domestic criticism of the deal among its citizens. According to Reuters, the Arabic hashtag “Gulfis_Against_Normalisation” was trending in third place on twitter in Saudi Arabia

Among the permanent members of the United Nations Security Council, UK, France and China also cheered the pact. Russia, which has balancing its ties between Israel and Iran, is the only P-5 to not issue a statement, even 24 hours after President Trump announced the agreement in Washington.

‘A Betrayal’: Israel-UAE Deal Leaves Palestinians Surprised, Dismayed

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, whose officials seemed to be taken by surprise, issued an unusually strong condemnation of a regional Arab neighbour.

Jerusalem: Israel talked of “history” and Palestinians of “betrayal” after Thursday’s surprise announcement of a deal to normalise relations between the Jewish state and the United Arab Emirates (UAE).

In a nationwide televised address, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said the deal would lead to “full and formal peace” with the Gulf Arab state and voiced hope that other countries in the region would follow the UAE’s example.

Netanyahu said it also entailed acceding to a request from U.S. President Donald Trump to “temporarily wait” on implementing the Israeli leader’s pledge to annex parts of the occupied West Bank.

“It’s an incomparably exciting moment, a historic moment for peace in the Middle East,” Netanyahu said.

Also read: Israel to ‘Suspend’ West Bank Annexation After Historic Deal with UAE, Announces Trump

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, whose officials seemed to be taken by surprise, issued an unusually strong condemnation of a regional Arab neighbour and instructed the Palestinian ambassador to the UAE to return immediately.

“The Palestinian leadership rejects and denounces the UAE, Israeli and U.S. trilateral, surprising announcement,” said Abbas’ spokesman Nabil Abu Rudeineh in Ramallah in the occupied West Bank.

Reading a statement on Palestinian television, Rudeineh said the leadership regarded the UAE’s move as “a betrayal”.

The statement urged the Arab League and the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation to assemble to “reject” the deal, adding “neither the UAE nor any other party has the right to speak in the name of the Palestinian people.”

The deal provides a diplomatic achievement for Netanyahu after weeks of domestic criticism over his handling of the coronavirus pandemic and the economy, but also angered right-wing Israeli settlers who want to annex the West Bank.

Netanyahu said that while he had promised to apply Israeli sovereignty to areas, including Jewish settlements in the territory, which Palestinians seek for a future state, he had made clear he first needed a green light from Washington.

“He deceived us. He has deceived half a million residents of the area and hundreds of thousands of voters,” said David Elhayani, head of the Yesha Council of settlers.

Pro-Israel stance

Abbas, who heads the Palestinian Authority and the umbrella Palestine Liberation Organization, has refused all political dealings with the Trump administration for more than two years, accusing it of taking a consistently pro-Israel stance.

Hanan Ashrawi, a veteran Palestinian negotiator, told Reuters: “We were blindsided. Their secret dealings are now completely out in the open. It is a complete sell-out.”

Much use was made of the word “normalisation” – a term that has very different connotations on either side.

For Israel and the White House, it signified a welcome rapprochement with a key Gulf player in a region from which Israel has long been isolated, aside from two peace treaties with its immediate neighbours Egypt and Jordan.

But for many Palestinians and Arabs in other countries, the word has overwhelmingly negative connotations.

In Gaza, Fawzi Barhoum, a spokesman for Hamas, told Reuters: “Normalisation is a stab in the back of the Palestinian cause, and it serves only the Israeli occupation.”

In a rare show of unity, Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh spoke to Abbas by phone to convey his “absolute rejection” of the deal, Hamas officials said.

There was no official reaction or media coverage in Saudi Arabia, but some Saudis tweeted under hashtags “normalization is treason”, “UAE” and “Israel.”

Mohammed Ali al-Houthi, the head of Yemen’s Iran-aligned Houthi group’s Supreme Revolutionary Committee, said the deal was a betrayal of the Palestinian cause and of pan-Arabism.

(Reuters)