Activist Who Led Shani Shingnapur Protest Hails Sabarimala Judgement

Trupti Desai called the SC order a victory for women’s constitutional rights and a setback for the patriarchal mentality and high-handedness of the temple trustees which had refused entry to women there.

Mumbai: Activist Trupti Desai, who led an agitation earlier to allow women to enter the Shani Shingnapur temple in Maharashtra, on Friday hailed the Supreme Court’s order on Kerala’s Ayyappa Temple at Sabarimala.

A five-judge constitution bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra, in its 4:1 verdict, on Friday said banning entry of women to Kerala’s Sabarimala temple is gender discrimination and the practice violates rights of Hindu women.

Desai told PTI that the SC order was a victory for women’s constitutional rights and a setback for the patriarchal mentality and high-handedness of the temple trustees which had refused entry to women there.

Desai said she planned to visit the Kerala temple soon.

Sabarimala Sree Dharma Sastha Temple, dedicated to Lord Ayyappa, is the most famous and prominent among all the Sastha temples in Kerala.

It is situated on a hilltop (about 3000 feet above sea level) named Sabarimala in Kerala’s Pathanamthitta district.

Desai’s Bhumata Ranragini Brigade had led an agitation to allow entry of women into Shani Shingnapur Temple in Ahmednagar district in Maharashtra.

The Bombay high court, in its order in April 2016, had allowed entry to women into the temple dedicated to Shani.

(PTI)

Trupti Desai Visits Haji Ali, Requests Dargah Trust to Not Move Supreme Court

The women’s rights activist hopes that the Haji Ali trust will not move the Supreme Court against the Bombay High Court’s decision.

Trupti Desai. Credit: PTI

Trupti Desai. Credit: PTI

Two days after the Bombay high court passed an order in favour of women entering the inner sanctum of the Haji Ali Dargah, Trupti Desai visited the dargah on Sunday, to offer a chadar and speak with the trust that runs it to urge them to not move the Supreme Court against the high court’s decision.

“I came to this place to pay my respects as our fight has been successful. Thankfully, unlike last time, there were no protests over my visit and I would like to thank everyone for this,” said Desai.

However, she could not meet the trustees as they were not there on a Sunday, the Indian Express reported.

“I request the trustees with folded hands to follow the verdict of the high court and not go to the Supreme Court to challenge the order as this was in favour of all the women in the country. If the trustees prefer to knock on the Supreme Court’s door, then nothing is going to change because the apex court too would uphold the constitutional right of the women and I am fully confident about it,” she said.

The women’s rights activist said,“If the trustees give a serious thought over the merits of the high court’s verdict, then it is possible that the doors of Baba can be opened in next two days only for the women devotees.”

This request comes after the high court order on Friday, which saw the barring of women as a violation of fundamental rights and said that the dargah’s trust had no right to prohibit women’s entry in a place of public worship. However, the court stayed its order for six weeks because the Haji Ali trust wanted challenge the order in the Supreme Court.

“Today I went only upto the permissible limit of the dargah, as I did not want to flout the court’s ruling in any case,” Desai said.

Desai said that the Sabrimala temple would be next on her quest to ensure that women are given equal rights in places of religious worship.

“I think that in the backdrop of the high court’s verdict, the trustees of the Sabarimala temple ought to open their doors for women discriminated on the basis of gender……And if they don’t, then I would launch a similar agitation and would speak to the management of the temple in next few days,” she said.

Desai, the president of the Bhumata Brigade, had launched a campaign earlier this year to ensure equal access for women in the Shani Shignapur temple in Ahmednagar, Maharashtra. They launched a similar campaign for the Haji Ali Dargah, after the Bharatiya Muslim Mahila Andolan petitioned the high court.

The seven trustees of the Haji Ali Dargah are due to meet today to discuss the situation. They can either approach the Supreme Court or they can remove the ban on women.

The Gender Beat: Bhumata Brigade Leader Assaulted; Former First Ladies Denounce Proposed Abortion Ban in Poland

A round-up of what’s happening in the worlds of gender and sexuality

A round-up of what’s happening in the worlds of gender and sexuality

A protest meeting organised for the 17-year-old dalit student found dead in her college after being raped. Credit: Beyond Headlines.

A protest meeting organised for the 17-year-old Dalit student found dead in her college after being raped. Credit: Beyond Headlines.

Trupti Desai physically assaulted inside temple

Bhumata Brigade leader Trupti Desai was beaten up by devotees and priests when she attempted to enter the sanctum sanctorum of the Mahalaxmi temple in Kohlapur last night, reports say. Desai attempted entry at night after being blocked by the police from entering during the day. Apparently, Desai was stopped because of ‘prohibitory orders’ against her entry. Reports say that these orders were imposed in anticipation of counter-protests from women’s groups belonging to Hindu nationalist organisations. Desai says that the act of stopping her group was violative of the Bombay high court judgement upholding women’s right to worship, which was at the centre of a campaign Desai and her group have been engaged in since late last year. A Supreme Court bench has also recently questioned the rationale behind the ban on women’s entry into the Sabrimala temple on constitutional grounds. Desai says that her attackers said they wanted to kill her. Desai has received death threats in the past.

Lack of rage, only silence for Dalit abuse

Author and poet Sharanya Manivannan has written in a piece published by The New Indian Express on the rape and death of a 17-year-old dalit student in Nokha, Rajasthan. Manivannan writes, “She is not the first woman — artist or otherwise to meet a tragic end because her talent stood at odds with what was expected of her. I don’t see Buzzfeed articles, neatly packaging tragedy for public consumption, with images of her paintings. I don’t see a government agency being set up in her name to provide arts scholarships for underprivileged girls.”

Manivannan asks why the circumstances of this death, including sexual violence, and the failure of the police to follow due process, do not provoke rage and protest from Indians in the way that the gangrape and murder of Jyoti Singh Pandey did. Read the piece here.

Delhi high court admits transgender woman’s name change plea

A Delhi-based transwoman has asked the Delhi high court to allow her to change her name and gender on official records. Officials had prevented her from changing her name because she has not undergone sex-reassignment surgery. However, under current laws, this surgery cannot be used as a reason to deny the request, and surgery cannot be forced upon transgender and gender-variant people. The high court has agreed to examine the plea.

The women dying for an abortion in Sierra Leone

Unsafe abortions account for an estimated 10% of total maternal deaths in Sierra Leone’s public hospitals, according to an Al Jazeera report. Abortion is illegal in Sierra Leone, so women and girls resort to dangerous methods to abort unwanted foetuses, leading to short- and long-term health problems. The country came close to allowing abortion last year – the report says the bill, if it had passed, would have allowed for “pregnancies to be terminated under any circumstances up to 12 weeks’ gestation and up to 24 weeks in cases of incest, rape, foetal impairment and when the woman’s health is at risk.” Although the bill passed through parliament, it was stopped because of objections from the country’s religious leaders.

Death toll in Handwara rises

Yesterday, The Wire reported on the deaths of two young men shot by the army in Handwara, Kashmir, following protests by locals against alleged sexual harassment by one or more army personnel. The situation has since escalated, and another person – a 70-year-old woman – has died. The police are saying that preliminary reports indicate that no sexual harassment took place. An Al Jazeera report says: “Rights groups, however, say such probes rarely yield any concrete results and are often aimed at calming public anger.” The report also quotes a local man, who spoke about the killing of the elderly woman: “She was working in her orchard 4km away from the protest site. The soldiers came and shot her. It’s a plain murder.”

Former first ladies denounce Poland’s proposed abortion ban

Three former first ladies of Poland have spoken out against a possible ban on abortion in the country, reports The Guardian. In an open letter, Danuta Wałęsa, Jolanta Kwaśniewska and Anna Komorowska have said that the total ban on abortion would “aggravate women’s tragedy” in the country, which has already enforced very strict abortion laws. There have been huge protests in Poland against a new proposal that will make it mandatory for women to give birth in all cases, except only when it is necessary to save the woman’s life.

Group of transgender people to be in charge of Kolkata polling booth

For the first time in history, a group of transgender people will be in charge of the polling processes at a booth in the West Bengal elections, to be held at the end of this month. An IBNLive report quotes district electoral officer Seema Pandey as saying, “This inclusion in polling process will be a part of their social engineering [sic] experience.” The same report says that activists are skeptical of the move. Pawan Dhall, a gender rights activist, has said this is “a cosmetic step” which does not reflect true equality granted to transgender people.

Two transgender candidates are contesting state elections this time.

Book award on women and labour

The National Women’s Studies Association in the USA has announced that it will award a new book award, called the Sara A. Whaley Book Prize, for “a monograph that addresses women and labour from intersectional perspectives.” Read their website for more details.

The Gender Beat: Temple Allows Women In, At Last; Kanhaiya Vs. Shekhar Gupta on Rapes by Soldiers

A round-up of what’s happening in the worlds of gender and sexuality

A round-up of what’s happening in the worlds of gender and sexuality

C Devi. Courtesy: The News Minute.

C Devi. Tamil Nadu’s first transgender candidate for the legislative assembly elections. Courtesy: The News Minute.

Shani Shingnapur temple allows women inside inner sanctum

The Shani Shingnapur temple has finally let women into its sanctum sanctorum, breaking a 400-year-old ban. In November 2015, women activists of the Bhumata Brigade, led by Trupti Desai, started campaigning to be let in.

Last week, the Bombay high court passed an order upholding women’s right to enter the inner sanctum. After days of defying the court, first by continuing to keep the women out, and then by banning everyone regardless of gender, the temple authorities gave in today.

So far, there are no reports of the skies falling or other signs of heavenly displeasure.

Judging Kanhaiya v. Shekhar Gupta on rapes by soldiers

In a Caravan Magazine piece, two co-authors of the book Do You Remember Kunan-Poshpora? (the other co-authors are Samreen Mushtaq, Ifrah Butt, and Munaza Rashid) address comments made by senior journalist Shekhar Gupta in response to Kanhaiya Kumar’s statements about sexual violence committed by the armed forces.

The writers, Essar Batool and Natasha Rather, argue that Gupta’s dismissal of Kumar’s statements reflects a larger problem of the Indian intelligentsia, who make it difficult to question any actions committed by members of the armed forces, no matter how heinous. Using various pieces of reportage, including the case of Major Rahman, who was found guilty of raping a woman and her child, the writers demonstrate how the acceptance of rampant sexual violence and the tendency to stereotype any questioning or dissent, adds to the impunity by members of the armed forces who commit sexual violence.

“The crimes committed by the army personnel are lost in the din of the respect they receive for their service. Even if what Gupta seemed to suggest in his tweet – that army personnel do not commit rapes in Kashmir any longer – were true, that does not mean that this is not a matter of great concern. Such statements are doubly harmful in a culture in which rape is stigmatised and reporting of such crimes, discouraged,” say the writers.

Colombia’s highest court paves way for marriage equality in surprise ruling

Magistrates at Colombia’s highest court defeated a proposed ruling that said marriage is only between a man and a woman. The proposed ruling also said that congress, and not the court, should make a decision on same-sex marriage.

Alberto Rojas, one of the magistrates who voted against the proposed ruling, said:“All human beings … have the fundamental right to be married with no discrimination.”

This ruling clears the ambiguity created by a vague court ruling on marriage equality passed in 2011.

Maharashtra government may rope in women’s commission to regulate dance bars

As part of a new series of proposed norms to regulate Maharashtra’s dance bars, the state women’s commission and members of women’s rights organisations may be asked to inspect dance bars.

Although the state government cannot go against the Supreme Court ruling which said an outright ban on dance bars is unconstitutional, it is going to place a draft bill before the legislative council to impose a set of stringent rules that bars have to comply with.

These include the ambiguous business of bar owners needing to ensure that the dance is not ‘obscene’ in any way. The role of the women’s commission may not necessarily be progressive either, considering comments made by members of the commission in the past. It is not clear whether any dancers’ unions have been consulted as part of this process.

Although some of the guidelines may be helpful, critics – who argue the state’s campaign against dance bars has done more harm than good – are likely to say the whole the exercise is a way of indirectly flouting the Supreme Court’s orders.

TN’s first transgender candidate is standing against Jayalalithaa

A transgender woman from Salem, who has worked for the rights of transgender persons, sex workers, and homeless people, is standing for the upcoming assembly elections in Tamil Nadu. C Devi, who is 33 years old, is the first transgender election candidate that the state has ever had.

An article in The News Minute quotes her as saying, “I’m going to focus on the upliftment of the poor, on providing clean drinking water and on better employment for the people in the constituency.”  Devi is contesting on behalf of the political party Naam Tamilar Katchi.

Global literary award for realistic portrayals of women characters

A global literary award, which comes with a US$ 50,000 cash prize, has been constituted for writers of short fiction, novels, and screenplays in English. Submissions are being sought across genres, and must portray at least one well-rounded woman protagonist. The award has been constituted by Half the World Holdings.

Students protest after NLSIU professor shames student for wearing shorts

When a third-year law student wore shorts to class at the National Law School of India University, she was asked by a professor to “dress properly.” In addition, the professor reportedly made disparaging remarks about the student’s ‘character.’ In protest, the entire third-year class showed up wearing shorts.

Students are now asking for an independent fact-finding committee to investigate the incident.

Why the Panama Papers are a feminist issue

Chiara Capraro and Francesca Rhodes argue in a piece on Open Democracy that “financial secrecy and tax avoidance are feminist issues.” They write that tax evasion by the wealthy in the Global North has a direct impact on the health and welfare of the poorest people in the world, and this impact is disproportionately felt by women.

“Our ambition is not, of course, to get to a point where there are as many female as male billionaires able to dodge taxes. Instead, we must fight for a fairer economy and a better politics in which both extreme poverty and extreme wealth are consigned to the history books,” say the writers.

If you want to receive regular updates from this column in your email, subscribe to our weekly gender newsletter.