India Urges Israel, Palestine to Engage With Each Other, Consider US Peace Plan

India, however, does acknowledge that any proposal must ‘be acceptable to both.’

New Delhi: Following the unveiling of US President Donald Trump’s new “peace plan” for the Middle East, India has said that the solution to the Israeli-Palestinian issue has to be “acceptable to both” sides, even as it urged both to actively engage with the US’s proposals.

Trump’s “deal of the century” allows for Israel to control a unified Jerusalem as its capital. Settlements on the West Bank will not be removed. Palestine will be allowed to have a restricted state with limited sovereignty, but only after the nation fulfils several conditions.

The ‘peace plan’, which had been in the pipeline since Trump took over, was announced by Trump alongside Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas has dismissed the deal as “unworthy of consideration.”

Also read: Trump’s Middle East ‘Peace Plan’ Delivers Neither

Abbas immediately denounced the plan as a “conspiracy deal” unworthy of serious consideration, making the decades-long pursuit of a so-called “two-state solution” appear more distant than ever.

“After the nonsense that we heard today we say a thousand ‘no’s to the ‘deal of the century’,” Abbas said in Ramallah on Tuesday.

In its official response, India on Wednesday urged that the final status should be “resolved through direct negotiations between the two Parties and be acceptable to both”.

With the Palestinians rejecting the proposal, negotiation is not the table.

However, India urged that both sides should also consider the US proposal as part of various other solutions that would necessitate “direct negotiations”.

“We urge the Parties to engage with each other, including on the recent proposals put forward by the United States, and find an acceptable two-state solution for peaceful coexistence. We will continue to follow developments in the region and engage with the Parties concerned,” said MEA spokesperson Raveesh Kumar.

India described itself as been a consistent supporter of the Palestinian cause and the two-state solution.

USAID Assistance in the West Bank and Gaza Has Ceased – Officials

The decision was linked to a January 31 deadline set by new US legislation under which foreign aid recipients would be more exposed to anti-terrorism lawsuits.

Jerusalem: The US Agency for International Development (USAID) has ceased all assistance to Palestinians in the occupied West Bank and Gaza, a US official said on Friday.

The halt was requested by the Palestinian Authority but is certain to bring further hardship to people in the already deprived territories.

The deadline also sees the end of about $60 million in US aid for the Palestinian security forces, whose cooperation with Israeli forces helps maintain relative quiet in the West Bank.

The decision was linked to a January 31 deadline set by new US legislation under which foreign aid recipients would be more exposed to anti-terrorism lawsuits.

The Anti-Terrorism Clarification Act (ATCA) empowers Americans to sue foreign aid recipients in US courts over alleged complicity in “acts of war”.

President Donald Trump’s Middle East envoy, Jason Greenblatt, said the aid was cut at the request of the Palestinian Authority.

“This aid was cut (not just suspended) at the PA’s request because they didn’t want to be subject to US courts which would require them to pay US citizens killed by Palestinian terrorists when the PA was found guilty,” he said in a tweet.

The Palestinian Authority declined further US funding over worries about its potential legal exposure, although it denies Israeli accusations that it encourages militant attacks.

Also read: Palestinian Prime Minister, Unity Government Resign

“At the request of the Palestinian Authority, we have wound down certain projects and programs funded with assistance under the authorities specified in ATCA in the West Bank and Gaza, a US official told Reuters on Friday.

“All USAID assistance in the West Bank and Gaza has ceased.”

It was unclear how long the cessation would last. The official said no steps were currently being taken to close the USAID mission in the Palestinian territories, and no decision had been made about future staffing at the USAID mission in the US Embassy in Jerusalem.

USAID is the main agency administering US foreign assistance in the Palestinian territories. According to its website, the agency spent $268 million on public projects in the West Bank and Gaza as well as Palestinian private sector debt repayment in 2017, but there were significant cuts to all new funding through the end of June 2018.

Nabil Abu Rudeineh, a spokesman for Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, said: “The suspension of aid to our people, which included critical sectors such as health and education, will have a negative impact on all, create a negative atmosphere, and increase instability.”

Greenblatt called Rudeineh’s statement disingenuous.

“Palestinians are too smart to continue to live as victims and recipients of foreign aid. Until a political solution is found (maybe it will be our peace plan?), the PA must focus on helping Palestinians lead better lives,” he tweeted.

The Palestinian Authority is an interim self-government body set up following the 1993 Oslo peace accords. The peace process, aimed at finding a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian

conflict, has been stalled since 2014.

In the Hamas-ruled enclave of Gaza, Hamas spokesman Ismail Rudwan condemned the cuts, deploring what he called “politicised money”.

Humanitarian cuts

The announcement comes after humanitarian officials in the West Bank and Gaza said they were already facing a cutback from donors worldwide.

Last year Washington cut hundreds of millions of dollars of aid to the Palestinians, which included funding to humanitarian groups supported by USAID.

The US cuts were widely seen as a means of pressuring the Palestinian leadership to resume the peace talks with Israel and to engage with the Trump administration ahead of its long-awaited Middle East peace plan.

As a result, dozens of NGO employees have been laid off, programmes shut down, and infrastructure projects halted.

In Gaza, Mohammad Ashour said he once earned $600 a month providing psychological support to people with chronic diseases such as high blood pressure, diabetes and cancer.

The project was run by the Palestinian Center for Democracy and Conflict Resolution. But, said Ashour, he lost his job last summer because the program was funded with the help of USAID money.

“I have no clue how am I going to pursue my life,” said Ashour, from Bureij refugee camp.

“I have no job and I am in debt, maybe tomorrow the police will come and take me to jail. An educated man ends in jail, I am wrecked.”

In August, Washington announced an end to all US funding for the UN agency that assists Palestinian refugees. The agency received $364 million from the United States in 2017.

In January the World Food Programme cut food aid to about 190,000 Palestinians due to a shortage of funds.

Diplomatic sources said Palestinian, US and Israeli officials were trying to find ways to keep the money flowing to Abbas’s security forces.

“We will find a solution to these things. I won’t get into details,” Israeli security cabinet minister Yuval Steinitz told Israel Radio on Thursday.

(Reuters)

Palestinian Prime Minister, Unity Government Resign

The government will continue to carry out its duties until a new one is formed, it said in a statement.

Ramallah, West Bank: Palestinian Prime Minister Rami Al-Hamdallah has tendered his resignation and that of his unity government to President Mahmoud Abbas, he said on Tuesday, dealing a blow to faltering reconciliation efforts with Gaza’s Islamist Hamas rulers.

The government will continue to carry out its duties until a new one is formed, it said in a statement issued after a weekly cabinet meeting.

There was no immediate comment from Abbas, but his Fatah faction, at a meeting he chaired two days ago, recommended that the government be replaced. A Hamas official condemned the move as an attempt to marginalise and exclude the group from Palestinian politics.

Hamdallah, a little-known academic, headed the national unity government formed in 2014 and led the West Bank-based Fatah’s reconciliation efforts with Hamas, which seized power in Gaza in 2007.

Also read: In Occupied Palestine, Children Come in the Line of Fire

The two groups signed a reconciliation deal two years ago which set in motion a plan for Abbas’s Palestinian Authority to resume governing in Gaza and take up control of the coastal enclave’s crossing points into Egypt and Israel.

But disputes over power-sharing and disagreements over policy towards Israel have hampered the deal’s implementation.

(Reuters) 

Trump Says He Wants Two-State Solution for Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

Trump, in a meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the United Nations, also said he wanted to unveil a peace plan in the next two to three months.

United Nations: US President Donald Trump said on Wednesday he wanted a two-state solution to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the clearest expression yet of his administration’s support for such an outcome.

The Trump administration has in the past said it would support a two-state solution if both sides agreed to it.

Trump, in a meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the United Nations, also said he wanted to unveil a peace plan in the next two to three months.

“I like a two-state solution. That’s what I think works best … That’s my feeling,” said Trump, who is attending the annual UN gathering of world leaders.

Netanyahu has said any future Palestinian state must be demilitarised and must recognise Israel as the state of the Jewish people – conditions that Palestinians say show he is not sincere about peacemaking.

The United States’ Arab allies are strong proponents of a two-state solution.

“I really believe something will happen. They say it’s the toughest of all deals,” Trump said.

Doubts have mounted over whether Trump’s administration can secure what he has called the “ultimate deal” since December, when the US President recognised Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and then moved the US Embassy there.

“It is a dream of mine to get that done prior to the end of my first term,” Trump said of an agreement on the conflict.

“I don’t want to do it in my second term. We’ll do other things in my second term,” he said. “I think a lot of progress has been made. I think that Israel wants to do something and I think that the Palestinians actually want to do something.”

Jerusalem is one of the major issues in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Both sides claim it as a capital. Trump’s move outraged the Palestinians, who have since boycotted Washington’s peace efforts, led by Trump’s son-in-law and adviser, Jared Kushner.

The Palestinians want to establish a state in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem. Israel captured those territories in the 1967 Middle East war and annexed East Jerusalem in a move not recognized internationally. It regards all of the city as its eternal and indivisible capital.

Nabil Abu Rdainah, a spokesman for Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, said: “In response to what Trump said about the two-state solution, the two-state solution means to us that we have a Palestinian state on the 1967 borders, with East Jerusalem as its capital. This is the only way to achieve peace.”

Rdainah said the Palestinians wanted to resolve all the core issues of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict – which include borders, settlements, refugees, security and the status of Jerusalem – “according to United Nations resolutions.”

Rdainah, speaking in Ramallah in the occupied West Bank, refused to be drawn further, saying President Abbas would make the Palestinian position clear in his speech to the General Assembly on Thursday.

Asked what Israel might have to give up in return for the embassy’s move to Jerusalem, Trump replied: “What will Israel have to give up after US embassy move to Jerusalem? I took probably the biggest chip off the table.

“And so obviously we have to make a fair deal, we have to do something. Deals have to be good for both parties … Israel got the first chip and it’s a big one.”

(Reuters) 

US Halts All Funding to UN Palestinian Relief Organisation

A spokesman for Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas denounced the decision as “a flagrant assault against the Palestinian people and a defiance of UN resolutions”.

Washington/Ramallah: The United States on Friday halted all funding to a UN agency that helps Palestinian refugees, in a decision further heightening tensions between the Palestinian leadership and the Trump administration.

A spokesman for Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas denounced the decision as “a flagrant assault against the Palestinian people and a defiance of UN resolutions”.

State Department spokeswoman Heather Nauert said the business model and fiscal practices of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) made it an “irredeemably flawed operation”.

“The administration has carefully reviewed the issue and determined that the United States will not make additional contributions to UNRWA,” she said in a statement.

Nauert said the agency’s “endlessly and exponentially expanding community of entitled beneficiaries is simply unsustainable and has been in crisis mode for many years.”

The latest announcement comes a week after the administration said it would redirect $200 million in Palestinian economic support funds for programs in the West Bank and Gaza.

UNRWA spokesman Chris Gunness voiced the agency’s “deep regret and disappointment” at the decision, which he said was surprising given that a December US funding agreement had acknowledged UNRWA’s successful management.

“We reject in the strongest possible terms the criticism that UNRWA’s schools, health centres, and emergency assistance programs are ‘irredeemably flawed,'” Gunness added in a series of Twitter posts.

The 68-year-old agency says it provides services to about 5 million Palestinian refugees in Jordan, Lebanon, Syria and the West Bank and Gaza. Most are descendants of people who were driven out of their homes or fled the fighting in the 1948 war that led to Israel’s creation.

US President Donald Trump and his aides say they want to improve the Palestinians’ plight, as well as start negotiations on an Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement.

But under Trump, Washington has taken a number of actions that have alienated the Palestinians, including the recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital. That move was a reversal of a longtime US policy and led the Palestinian leadership to boycott the Washington peace efforts being led by Jared Kushner, Trump’s senior adviser and son-in-law.

The United States paid out $60 million to UNRWA in January, withholding another $65 million, from a promised $365 million for the year.

A Palestinian employee of United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) holds a sign that reads, " no for political blackmail and starvation policy" during a protest against a U.S. decision to cut aid, in Gaza City January 29, 2018. Credits: Reuters/Mohammed Salem/Files

A Palestinian employee of United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) holds a sign that reads, ” no for political blackmail and starvation policy” during a protest against a US decision to cut aid, in Gaza City, January 29, 2018. Credits: Reuters/Mohammed Salem/Files

‘Not part of the solution’

“Such a punishment will not succeed to change the fact that the United States no longer has a role in the region and that it is not a part of the solution,” Abbas spokesman Nabil Abu Rdainah told Reuters.

He said “neither the United States nor anybody else will be able to dissolve” UNRWA.

In Gaza, the Islamist group Hamas condemned the US move as a “grave escalation against the Palestinian people.”

“The American decision aims to wipe out the right of return and is a grave US escalation against the Palestinian people,” said Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri.

He told Reuters the “US leadership has become an enemy of our people and of our nation and we will not surrender before such unjust decisions.”

Earlier on Friday, German Foreign Minister Heiko Maas said Germany would increase its contributions to UNRWA because the funding crisis was fuelling uncertainty. “The loss of this organisation could unleash an uncontrollable chain reaction,” Maas said.

UNRWA has faced a cash crisis since the United States, long its biggest donor, slashed funding earlier this year, saying the agency needed to make unspecified reforms and calling on the Palestinians to renew peace talks with Israel.

The last Palestinian-Israeli peace talks collapsed in 2014, partly because of Israel’s opposition to an attempted unity pact between the Fatah and Hamas Palestinian factions and Israeli settlement building on occupied land that Palestinians seek for a state.

Nauert said the United States would intensify talks with the United Nations, the region’s governments and international stakeholders that could involve bilateral US assistance for Palestinian children.

“We are very mindful of and deeply concerned regarding the impact upon innocent Palestinians, especially school children, of the failure of UNRWA and key members of the regional and international donor community to reform and reset the UNRWA way of doing business,” she said.

Gunness told Reuters earlier in August that UNRWA’s support would be needed as long as the parties failed to reach an agreement to end the crisis.

“UNRWA does not perpetuate the conflict, the conflict perpetuates UNRWA,” he said. “It is the failure of the political parties to resolve the refugee situation which perpetuates the continued existence of UNRWA.”

(Reuters)

Israel Says Gaza Truce Talks Focus on Easing Blockade, in Return for Calm

Gaza, under years of grinding Israeli and Egyptian sanctions aimed at isolating Hamas, has seen a surge in tensions since Palestinians launched weekly border protests on March 30.

Jerusalem/Gaza: Israel set out limited goals for Gaza truce talks on Sunday (August 5), saying the focus was on a proposal to ease its blockade of the Islamist Hamas-controlled territory in return for the Palestinians calming their side of the frontier.

The Israeli statement came hours before Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu convened his security cabinet to discuss, and possibly approve UN-and Egyptian-brokered ideas for preventing another threatened Gaza war.

A very brief statement issued after the meeting ended revealed little. It said that Israel‘s military chief had briefed the cabinet about the situation in the Gaza Strip and that the army was “prepared for any scenario.”

The UN and Egypt have not publicly detailed their proposals. They have spoken generally of a need to improve humanitarian conditions in Gaza, stem cross-border hostilities and reconcile Hamas – which refuses formal peacemaking with Israel – to its Western-backed Palestinian rivals.

Gaza, under years of grinding Israeli and Egyptian sanctions aimed at isolating Hamas, has seen a surge in tensions since Palestinians launched weekly border protests on March 30, drawing Israeli army fire that has killed at least 157 people.

There have also been shelling exchanges between Hamas-led militants and Israel in which around 10 Palestinian gunmen and four civilians have died, Gaza sniper attacks that killed an Israeli soldier and wounded another, and wide-scale brushfires set in Israelby incendiary kites and helium balloons from Gaza.

Israel responded on July 9 by shuttering Gaza‘s main commercial terminal and limiting a Palestinian fishing zone off the enclave, measures it offered to reverse on Sunday.

“A complete ceasefire (by the Palestinians) will lead, on Israel‘s part, to the reopening of the Kerem Shalom crossing and renewal of the permits given in respect to the fishing zones,” said the Israeli official, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

This offer would be the focus of Sunday’s deliberations, the official said, adding that any eventual broader agreement over Gaza would require a guarantee for the return of the remains of two Israeli soldiers killed in the 2014 Israel-Hamas war, and two civilians lost in Gaza.

Hamas has linked their fate to Israel freeing Palestinian security detainees – something many Israelis oppose.

Zur Goldin (R), brother of Israeli soldier Hadar Goldin, and other family members talk to the media outside their home in the central Israeli city of Kfar Saba August 2, 2014. Credit: Reuters/Nir Elias

Hamas, which convened several of its top leaders to Gaza last week for consultations, also sounded circumspect on Sunday.

“Hamas has conducted internal meetings that have not yet ended,” one senior official, Hussam Badran, told a Gaza radio station.

“The suffering of our people, and the 12-year blockade imposed with no guilt on their part, requires that all Palestinian leaders search for a real solution to this suffering … without giving concessions when it comes to the known and outstanding positions and rights of our people.”

More than two million Palestinians, mostly the stateless descendants of people who were driven out or fled from territory that is now Israel at its founding in 1948, are packed into the narrow strip.

Israel withdrew its troops and settlers from Gaza in 2005, but maintains tight control of its land and sea borders. Egypt also restricts movement in and out of Gaza on its border.

Israel, the US and other Western countries regard Hamas as a terrorist organisation. Israel and Hamas have fought three wars since 2008, the last of them in 2014.

The Fatah movement of Western-backed Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas who holds sway in the Israeli-occupied West Bank has denounced the talks. A spokesman said any deal risked ending hopes of achieving Palestinian statehood.

“(A deal would bring about a) separation of Gaza from the rest of the homeland and would create a mini-state which will be the graveyard of our national project,” said Munir Al-Ghaghoub, a spokesman for Abbas’s Fatah movement.

But after a meeting of Palestinian faction representatives including Fatah, Hamas’s Badran said: “There will be no state in Gaza and no state without Gaza.”

In what appeared to be a confidence-building gesture by Cairo, a pro-Hamas website said Egypt was on Sunday beginning to allow cooking gas across its border to Gaza to make up for the shortfall in Israeli supplies.

Also on Sunday, the Israeli military said it fired toward a vehicle used by Palestinian balloon-launchers in Gaza on Sunday. Palestinian medics said four people were wounded.

Israel‘s defence ministry released first images of the barrier it has built along the border with the Gaza Strip that stretches into the sea, and which it began constructing two months ago.

Built up with rocks and gravel, it stretches 200 metres from the shore into the Mediterranean. It is 50 metres wide and a six-metre high steel fence is placed next to it facing the Gaza side which will have surveillance devices placed on it.

(Reuters)

Violence Erupts in Gaza, Heaviest Flare-up Since 2014 War

This conflict comes just weeks after over 100 Palestinian unarmed protestors were killed by Israeli forces.

Gaza-Israel Border: Palestinian militants launched their heaviest barrages against Israel since the 2014 Gaza war on May 29 and Israeli aircraft struck back, in a surge of fighting after weeks of border violence.

Following militant rocket and mortar launches throughout the day countered by Israeli tank fire and air strikes, the pro-Iran Islamic Jihad militant group said a ceasefire agreement was possible, but Israel said reports of a deal were untrue.

“Palestinian factions will abide by calm as long as (Israel) abides by it,” Islamic Jihad spokesman Daoud Shehab said. An Israeli official who declined to be named said, “The report about a ceasefire is incorrect.”

Israeli sirens warning of imminent rocket and mortar strikes sounded late into the night and Israelaircraft hit 55 militant targets in the Gaza Strip, including a cross-border tunnel under construction, the military said.

Israel has long said it would not tolerate such attacks. There was no sign that calm would be restored at midnight (21:00 GMT), when the militants said the ceasefire could take effect.

The Israeli military said that by 8 pm local time (1700 GMT) militants had fired 70 rockets and mortar bombs into Israel and that three Israeli soldiers were wounded by shrapnel. There were no immediate reports of Palestinian casualties.

The armed wings of Hamas and Islamic Jihad claimed responsibility for the firing and said it was in response to Israel‘s killing of dozens of Palestinians since March 30, mainly in Gaza border protests.

“Qassam and Jerusalem Brigades (the groups’ armed wings) announce joint responsibility for bombarding (Israel‘s) military installations and settlements near Gaza with dozens of rocket shells throughout the day,” they said in a joint statement.

“It comes in response to Zionist aggression and crimes against our people and our resistance fighters … in addition to war crimes conducted by the enemy every day against our people during the marches of return along the border of Gaza Strip.

“Bombardment for bombardment and blood for blood.”

Hamas has largely abided by a de-facto ceasefire since the 2014 war.

“Threshold of war”

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu convened security chiefs, and Intelligence Minister Israel Katz said the country was “at the closest point to the threshold of war” since the seven-week conflict with Palestinian militants four years ago.

“If the firing (from Gaza) does not stop, we will have to escalate our responses and it could lead to a deterioration of the situation,” Katz said on Army Radio.

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, who heads the Fatah faction that is dominant in the occupied West Bank and is a bitter rival of Hamas and Islamic Jihad, said Israel had used “vigorous aggression” against Gaza that proved it did not want peace.

Lieutenant-Colonel Jonathan Conricus, a spokesman for the Israel Defence Forces (IDF), said the most extensive strikes from Gaza since the 2014 war had drawn “the largest IDF retaliatory attack” since that conflict.

Several militant projectiles were shot down by Israel‘s Iron Dome rocket interceptor system, others landed in empty lots and farmland. One exploded in a kindergarten yard, damaging walls and scattering debris and shrapnel around the playground, about an hour before it was scheduled to open for the day.

Violence has soared along the Gaza frontier in recent weeks, during which 116 Palestinians were killed by Israeli fire at mass demonstrations calling for Palestinians’ right to return to ancestral lands now in Israel.

A Hamas spokesman defended Tuesday’s attacks as a “natural response to Israeli crimes”. An Islamic Jihad spokesman said, “the blood of our people is not cheap”.

Explosions in Gaza

Plumes of smoke and dust rose from sites hit in the Israeli air strikes. The explosions shook buildings nearby, causing panic among rush-hour crowds on streets and in markets. The Gazan Ministry of Education said shrapnel from one missile flew into a school.

Nickolay Mladenov, the United Nations’ special coordinator for the Middle East peace process, said he was deeply concerned by “the indiscriminate firing of rockets by Palestinian militants from Gaza towards communities in southern Israel“.

Amid international condemnation of its use of lethal force at the mass demonstrations that began on March 30, Israel said many of the dead were militants and that the army was repelling attacks on the border fence.

Palestinians and their supporters said most of the protesters were unarmed civilians and Israel was using excessive force against them.

Off Gaza‘s coast on Tuesday, the Israeli navy intercepted a boat that organisers of the Palestinian border protests launched from the enclave in a challenge to an Israeli maritime blockade.

The military said the vessel was stopped without major incident and was towed to the Israeli port of Ashdod where the 17 people on board would be questioned. The organiser of the boat protest said 14 of the boat’s passengers had been returned by land to Gaza but three were detained.

More than two million Palestinians are packed into the narrow coastal enclave. Israel withdrew its troops and settlers from Gaza in 2005 but, citing security concerns, maintains tight control of its land and sea borders, which has reduced its economy to a state of collapse.

Egypt also restricts movement in and out of Gaza on its border.

(Reuters)

In Palestine for Three Hours, Modi Drops Indian Support for ‘United’, ‘Viable’ Palestinian State

The shift in nuance means the Modi government is no longer insisting that Israel’s illegal occupation of Palestinian territory be ended in toto.

The shift in nuance means the Modi government is no longer insisting that Israel’s illegal occupation of Palestinian territory be ended in toto.

President Mahmoud Abbas of Palestine and Prime Minister Narendra Modi of India in Ramallah on February 10, 2018. Credit: Reuters

New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi may have been the first Indian prime minister to make an official visit to Palestine but his three-hour stopover in Ramallah on Saturday saw him produce another first – a dilution of  India’s position that Israel would have to end its illegal occupation of all Palestinian territory, including East Jerusalem, in order for Palestine to achieve full independence and statehood.

 

In a prepared speech delivered in the presence of Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas, Modi endorsed a “sovereign, independent” Palestine, but dropped two crucial adjectives – ‘united’ and ‘viable’. These now join a list of words that already appear to have disappeared from the Indian diplomatic playbook including a “two state solution” to the conflict between Israel and Palestine and ‘East Jerusalem as capital’ of a future Palestinian state.

Observers believe the dropping of the latest two words – or principles – is perhaps a result of New Delhi hedging its bets on the new ‘peace plan’ proposed by the United States and backed by the Israelis.

On February 10, Prime Minister Modi – who flew in to Ramallah from Amman, Jordan by helicopter after meeting the Jordanian king – stood next to President Abbas and said in Hindi, “भारत, फिलीस्तीन के शांतिपूर्ण माहौल में शीघ्र एक संप्रभू, स्वतंत्र देश बनने की आशा करता है। (India hopes to see a sovereign, independent state of Palestine in a peaceful manner soon).”

The latest change in semantics comes less than two months after Modi’s articulation of the traditional Indian position on Palestine. On November 25, he had issued a statement on the occasion of the international day of solidarity with Palestine. “We hope for early realisation of a sovereign, independent, united and viable Palestine state, coexisting peacefully with Israel,” he said.

Even when Modi last stood publicly next to Abbas in May 2017 in New Delhi, he had specifically mentioned the hope for a “sovereign, independent, united and viable Palestinian state”. India had invited the Palestinian president to India ahead of Modi’s trip to Israel, which, in a break from Indian diplomatic tradition, was scheduled only as a stand-alone visit to the Jewish state and not to Palestine.

P.R. Kumaraswaramy, a West Asian expert at the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses in New Delhi had noted at the time that Modi’s reference to a “united’ Palestine meant that India “differs with the current Israeli government which is gravitating towards a one-state solution, namely, Israel without a Palestinian state”. He noted that Palestinians have been effectively living for a decade under two political entities – the West Bank under the Palestine National Authority, and Gaza, ruled by the Islamist Palestinian party Hamas.

Support for a united and viable Palestinian state means opposing the ongoing Israeli attempts to carve out huge tracts of Palestinian land (and acquifers) in the occupied West Bank for Israeli settlers. But with the growing bonhomie between Modi and Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, the Indian side appears to be diluting its opposition to the Israeli occupation.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi receives the Grand Collar – the highest order given to foreign dignitaries – by President Mahmoud Abbas of Palestine after the conclusion of their bilateral meeting in Ramallah on Saturday. Credit: PIB/PTI

A former Indian diplomat who had dealt with India’s West Asia policy while in office said that the dropping of the words ‘united’ and ‘viable’ was perhaps a reflection of New Delhi’s understanding that there was no going back to the pre-1967 borders, before Israel illegally occupied the West Bank and Gaza. “Palestinian territories are now no longer contiguous. There are scattered all over with Israeli land in between,” he said.

The new Modi formulation is also in line with Israel’s ruling Likud party position that Palestine should not have access to ports and airports in order to ensure the security of Israel.

According to A.K. Pasha, a professor of West Asian studies at Jawaharlal Nehru University, the dropping of ‘united’ and ‘viable’ by India “had to be seen in terms of ground realities, which the Israelis are presenting as a fait accompli in the current peace plan”.

Zikrur Rahman, who was India’s diplomatic representative to Palestine from 2006 to 2008, said that there has definitely been a big shift from India on Palestine as demonstrated by Modi’s remarks.

“India’s historical position and unwavering support for a sovereign, independent, contiguous Palestine state co-existing peacefully with Israel with East Jerusalem as capital, is not being reiterated…. India is avoiding it,” he told The Wire.

Rahman also noted that while the Indian prime minister had made a visit to Palestine, the changes in India’s public statements marked a subtle shift in support of Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s stated position. “The Israelis are creating facts on the ground which are being touted as ground realities,” he said.

Pasha pointed out that Israel had been courting regional powers like Egypt, Saudi Arabia and the UAE on the Palestinian issue as part of its overall strengthening of ties with the Arab world against Iran. However, Rahman said that it would be very difficult for an Arab state to give up on core issues like East Jerusalem.

Following President Donald Trump’s decision to shift the US embassy to Jerusalem, India issued a rather tepid response that led the Palestinian envoy to call for a stronger statement from New Delhi.

India, however, did cast a ‘yes’ vote on the Arab league-sponsored resolution in the UN General Assembly that called upon the US not to take any steps that would alter the status of Jerusalem.

Modi did not refer to the two-state solution in his Ramallah speech, in keeping with the fact that this concept has lately been absent from Indian diplomatic statements over the last one year – including in Modi’s remarks in May 2017 during the visit of the Palestinian president.

During Modi’s visit to Ramallah on Sunday, India and Palestine exchanged five agreements, which includes the of setting up a $30 million super-speciality hospital, a women’s empowerment centre, a national printing press, two schools and a floor for a new school. India has also agreed to set up an Institute of Diplomacy in Palestine.

Palestinians See Gaza Peace Dividend Pass Them By

Three months on, discount stickers still adorn goods from clothes to cars but few of the two million people in the enclave blockaded by Israel are buying.

Palestinian children play on a beach at Al-Shati refugee camp in Gaza City January 15, 2018. Credit: Reuters/Mohammed Salem

Palestinian children play on a beach at Al-Shati refugee camp in Gaza City January 15, 2018. Credit: Reuters/Mohammed Salem

Gaza: Life began to look up for Gaza‘s Palestinians when reconciliation between its Hamas Islamist rulers and the West Bank-based Palestinian Authority in October brought a drop in crippling prices.

Three months on, discount stickers still adorn goods from clothes to cars but few of the two million people in the enclave blockaded by Israel are buying.

Although Hamas handed administrative control to the Western-backed PA, which lifted tax surcharges Hamas had imposed on businesses, making room for the price cuts, the rival leaderships are still arguing.

The result is that Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, who heads the PA, has not reversed a 30% wage cut he imposed in April on 60,000 civil servants who stayed on the PA’s payroll when the authority lost control of Gaza to Hamas in 2007.

Many of those employees are now mired in debt to banks for loans they took out to get by.

The salary reductions “deprived the Gaza market of $160 million in the past eight months”, said Maher al-Tabbaa, an official with the Chamber of Commerce.

For individuals, the consequences are stark. In a Gaza pharmacy this week, Umm Ahmed considered which medicines on the prescription she had been given for her son she could afford.

“Even in my dreams I never thought we would live through such misery,” she said as she chose two painkillers and left more expensive antibiotics in the drug store.

Tabbaa said any economic improvement in Gaza was largely dependent on Israel lifting the tight border restrictions it imposed after Hamas took power, a view that echoes World Bank reports over the years.

Israel cites security concerns for the measures, which include a naval blockade, an almost blanket ban on exports from the territory and restrictions on the import of items such as steel in case militants use them to make arms or fortifications.

Battling an Islamist insurgency in the Sinai desert that borders Gaza, Egypt, the main mediator of inter-Palestinian reconciliation, also invokes security considerations in keeping its border with the enclave largely closed.

International concern

Many countries, concerned over deepening economic hardship in Gaza, have urged more open borders.

The World Bank said in September alleviating restrictions on the movement of goods and people would allow critical trade to rebuild infrastructure and economy, both hit hard by a seven-week war between Israel and Gaza militants in 2014.

Some 550 Gaza traders had permission to enter Israel as of December 2017, a drop of 85% since late 2015, according to a Palestinian committee that transfers entry requests to Israeli authorities.

Israel has said some permits were used to arrange smuggling of material, weapons or money to militants.

The World Bank projected real GDP growth of 4% in Gaza for 2017, not enough to prevent a near stagnation in real per capita income and an increase in unemployment.

Tabbaa put current unemployment in Gaza at 46%.

Weak sales

“Metro” the second largest supermarket in Gaza, said sales had dropped to their lowest point since the business opened several years ago.

“People are only buying the very basic things, the most important of the important stuff,” Khalil al-Yazji, one of the owners, said. “We are unable to cover operating costs.”

The supermarket has dropped some staff and cut back on imports, fearing new stocks would only expire on the shelves.

In Gaza‘s once bustling Old Market, spice store owner Mamdouh Zeineldeen said he might have to close his business.

“Markets are collapsing, just like reconciliation,” he said.

The effects of armed conflict and economic woes in Gaza are also evident at Kerem Shalom, the only commercial crossing between Israel and the territory.

Some 800 to 1,000 truckloads of goods for Gaza pass through Kerem Shalom every day, but Tabbaa said that number dropped to 400 in recent weeks after merchants cut imports due to weak consumer demand.

Tensions have also risen since President Donald Trump reversed decades of US policy on December 6 by recognising Jerusalem as Israel’s capital.

Sixteen Palestinian protesters have been killed in clashes with police and Gaza militants have launched 18 cross-border rockets or mortar bombs into Israel, which has responded with air strikes. The exchange of fire has largely avoided casualties, but two Palestinian gunmen were killed in one retaliatory strike.

Israel closed Kerem Shalom on Saturday, a day before it destroyed what it said was a Hamas attack tunnel running underneath the facility.

The crossing reopened on Tuesday but further easing looks unlikely.

Hamas and the Palestinian Authority are still divided over the fate of 40,000 to 50,000 employees hired by Hamas since its 2007 takeover of Gaza. Security is another key sticking point, with Hamas still running the police and internal security in Gaza after handing administrative control to the PA.

Peace talks between Israel and Abbas’s Palestinian Authority collapsed in 2014 and Palestinian unity was supposed to strengthen Abbas’s hand in his bid to establish a state in the West Bank and Gaza.

But Israel has balked at the reconciliation efforts, saying it would not negotiate with a Palestinian government dependent on support by Hamas, a group that advocates its destruction.

(Reuters)

Condemning Trump’s Move, Muslim Leaders Urge East Jerusalem’s Recognition as Palestinian Capital

Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan, who hosted the summit of more than 50 Muslim countries in Istanbul, said the US move meant Washington had forfeited its role as broker in efforts to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas speaks during a news conference following the extraordinary meeting of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) in Istanbul, Turkey, December 13, 2017. Credit: Reuters/Osman Orsal

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas speaks during a news conference following the extraordinary meeting of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) in Istanbul, Turkey, December 13, 2017. Credit: Reuters/Osman Orsal

Istanbul: Muslim leaders on Wednesday condemned US President Donald Trump’s recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and called on the world to respond by recognising east Jerusalem as the capital of Palestine.

Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan, who hosted the summit of more than 50 Muslim countries in Istanbul, said the US move meant Washington had forfeited its role as broker in efforts to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

“From now on, it is out of the question for the biased United States to be a mediator between Israel and Palestine, that period is over,” Erdogan said at the end of the meeting of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation member states.

“We need to discuss who will be a mediator from now on. This needs to be tackled in the UN too,” Erdogan said.

A communique posted on the Turkish Foreign Ministry website said the emirs, presidents and ministers gathered in Istanbul regarded Trump’s move “as an announcement of the US Administration’s withdrawal from its role as sponsor of peace”.

It described the decision as “a deliberate undermining of all peace efforts, an impetus (for) extremism and terrorism, and a threat to international peace and security”.

Leaders including Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, Iran’s President Hassan Rouhani and Jordan’s King Abdullah, a close US ally, all criticised Washington’s move.

Jerusalem is and always will be the capital of Palestine,” Abbas said, adding Trump’s decision was “the greatest crime” and a violation of international law.

Asked about the criticism at a State Department briefing in Washington, spokeswoman Heather Nauert said that despite the “inflammatory rhetoric” from the region, Trump “is committed to this peace process.”

“That type of rhetoric that we heard has prevented peace in the past,” she said, urging people to “ignore some of the distortions” and focus on what Trump actually said. She said his decision did not affect the city’s final borders, which were dependent upon a negotiation between Israel and the Palestinians.

But when asked whether East Jerusalem could similarly be recognised as the capital of a future Palestinian state, Nauert said that determination should be left to final status negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians.

Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu makes a speech during a meeting of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) Foreign Ministers Council in Istanbul, Turkey, December 13, 2017. Credit: Reuters/Emrah Yorulmaz/Pool

Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu makes a speech during a meeting of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) Foreign Ministers Council in Istanbul, Turkey, December 13, 2017. Credit: Reuters/Emrah Yorulmaz/Pool

“We’re taking a position on how we view Jerusalem,” she said. “I think it’s up to the Israelis and Palestinians to decide how they want to view the borders – again final status negotiations.”

Abbas told OIC leaders in Istanbul that Washington had shown it could no longer be an honest broker.

“It will be unacceptable for it to have a role in the political process any longer since it is biased in favour of Israel,” he said. “This is our position and we hope you support us in this.”

Palestinian capital

Jerusalem, revered by Jews, Christians and Muslims alike, is home to Islam’s third holiest site and has been at the heart of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict for decades. Israel captured Arab East Jerusalem in 1967 and later annexed it in an action not recognised internationally.

The communique on the Turkish ministry website and a separate “Istanbul Declaration” distributed to journalists after the meeting said the leaders called on all countries to recognise East Jerusalem as the capital of Palestine.

“We invite the Trump administration to reconsider its unlawful decision that might trigger…chaos in the region, and to rescind its mistaken step,” the declaration said.

Iran, locked in a regional rivalry with Saudi Arabia, said the Muslim world should overcome internal problems through dialogue so it could unite against Israel. Tehran has repeatedly called for the destruction of the Israeli state and backs several militant groups in their fight against it.

“America is only seeking to secure the maximum interests of the Zionists and it has no respect for the legitimate rights of Palestinians,” Rouhani told the summit.

King Abdullah, whose country signed a peace treaty with Israel more than 20 years ago, said he rejected any attempt to alter the status quo of Jerusalem and its holy sites.

Abdullah’s Hashemite dynasty is the custodian of Jerusalem‘s Muslim sites, making Amman sensitive to any changes in the city.

Not all countries were represented by heads of government. Some sent ministers and Saudi Arabia, another close ally of Washington’s, sent a junior foreign minister.

Summit host Turkey has warned that Trump’s decision would plunge the world into “a fire with no end in sight”.

Erdogan described it as a reward for Israeli actions including occupation, settlement construction, land seizure and “disproportionate violence and murder”.

“Israel is an occupying state (and) Israel is a terror state,” he told the summit.

“I invite all countries supporting international law to recognise Jerusalem as the occupied capital of Palestine,” Erdogan told OIC leaders and officials.

Trump’s declaration has been applauded by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who said Washington had an irreplaceable part to play in the region.

(Reuters)